# 3Commas review: what it does, whether it is safe, and what to use instead

3Commas runs DCA, grid and signal bots on your exchange account through API keys. Here is what it does well, what happened in December 2022, where it stops, and who should look elsewhere.

- URL: https://www.ethyai.app/blog/3commas-review
- Author: Ethy Team
- Published: November 17, 2026; updated: November 17, 2026
- Publisher: Ethy AI, https://www.ethyai.app/

**The short answer:** As of November 17, 2026, 3Commas is a crypto bot platform: DCA, grid and signal bots that trade on your own exchange account through API keys, with a demo account and an AI assistant on paid plans. In December 2022 a third party disclosed some users’ API keys. Create keys that can trade but never withdraw.

## What is 3Commas, and who makes it?

3Commas is software for automating crypto trades on exchanges you already use. You do not deposit with 3Commas. You create an API key at your exchange (a password-like key that lets one app place orders on your account) and paste it into 3Commas, which then trades for you by rules. Its [about page](https://3commas.io/about) says it has been “trusted worldwide since 2017” and gives its head office as 3C Trade Tech Ltd., with an address in the British Virgin Islands, and its pages say “3Commas provides software only.”

The product changed a lot in 2026. 3Commas’ help center says the first version, V1, was deactivated on September 11, 2026, and that V2, “the successor to 3Commas,” was built in partnership with WunderTrading, “an established automated-trading platform” ([V2 guide](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16245835-3commas-v2-everything-you-need-to-know)). V2 is a new platform with a new account: you reconnect your exchange and rebuild your strategies, because they “do not transfer to v2 automatically.” That matters when you read reviews: most of what is written online describes V1.

One more change you may notice. On November 17, 2026, some visits to the 3Commas home page, and at times to its other pages, were redirected to quantpilot.com, while other visits loaded the 3Commas pages as usual. The V2 guide describes QuantPilot as “a new AI-powered trading product developed by the 3Commas team” for building and running strategies with AI, and says “3Commas.io continues working.” Another help center article says signing in to QuantPilot with a 3Commas account ended on September 11, 2026 ([QuantPilot access guide](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16394733-how-to-access-your-quantpilot-account-after-3commas-sign-in-ended)).

This review reads the company’s own pages, dated November 17, 2026, plus reporting and regulators where we cite them. We did not trade with it, and we do not quote star ratings or user reviews. If you are still comparing tools, our list of the [best AI trading bots](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/best-ai-trading-bots) puts it next to eleven others.

WunderTrading itself is covered in [our WunderTrading review](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/wundertrading-review).

## What does 3Commas do well?

- **Several bot types in one place.** V2 has a DCA bot (it buys in steps, and it also holds the indicator-based bots, such as RSI), a signal bot driven by TradingView alerts or API requests, a grid bot, and a Terminal for manual trades that replaced Smart Trade ([migration guide](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16300161-moving-from-3commas-v1-to-3commas-v2-feature-bot-migration-guide)). The Terminal can send one trade to up to 50 API keys at once ([Terminal guide](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16281054-trading-terminal-overview)). How these bots work is in our guides to [grid bots](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/grid-trading-bot) and [DCA](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/dca-crypto).
- **Nine exchanges.** Its pricing page lists nine, and its AI page shows Binance, Hyperliquid, Bybit, OKX, Bitget, Gate, Kraken, KuCoin and Coinbase. Hyperliquid, an onchain exchange for perpetual futures, is new with V2.
- **A demo account.** New demo accounts start with $10,000 of virtual funds that you can reset, use real-time market prices, and are limited to two ([demo guide](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16281106-demo-trading-guide)). The pricing page lists a demo account on every plan.
- **An AI assistant that builds the bot.** You describe a strategy in plain language and, in 3Commas’ words, the AI “configures, backtests, and launches the bot for you.” It asks follow-up questions, lets you edit the settings before launch, and says backtests “don’t predict the future” ([AI page](https://3commas.io/ai-trading-bot)).
- **Hooks for your own signals.** Webhook execution and Pine Script execution (TradingView’s scripting language) are listed on every plan.
- **A connection for your own AI app.** A help center guide shows how to link Claude, Cursor or another app that supports MCP (Model Context Protocol, a standard way for AI apps to use outside tools) to your 3Commas account with a 3Commas API key. The app can then check your strategies and history, or open and close strategies when you ask; the guide recommends a read-only key for everyday questions ([MCP guide](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16527454-connect-your-ai-assistant-to-3commas-mcp)).
- **No withdrawal rights needed.** Its security page says the platform “has zero access to withdraw or transfer fiat or cryptocurrencies.”

## How does 3Commas connect to your exchange, and what permissions should you give?

3Commas “connects to your exchange accounts using API keys,” and its [security page](https://3commas.io/security) says you “cannot withdraw funds either directly from 3Commas or via 3Commas.” On some exchanges, Fast Connect lets you log in to the exchange from 3Commas and creates the key for you. Your coins stay at your exchange. The weak point is the key itself: whoever holds it can do whatever its permissions allow. So set it up like this:

1. **Give it trading rights only** Turn on read and trade. Leave withdrawals off. 3Commas says the same on its AI page: use trade-only keys with withdrawals disabled.
2. **Add an IP allowlist** Most exchanges let you restrict a key to chosen IP addresses. 3Commas tells you to authorize its official IP addresses and block all others.
3. **Use a sub-account if your exchange has them** Put only the money the bot may trade in it, so a bad key can reach only that.
4. **Turn on two-factor authentication** On the exchange and on 3Commas. Both are in its security advice.
5. **Rotate the key** Delete the key at the exchange when you stop using a bot, and create a new one if you ever doubt it.

A key without withdrawal rights still lets someone place trades, which can hurt you on a thin market or with leverage. Limits on keys reduce the damage; they do not remove it.

## Is 3Commas safe? What happened in December 2022?

The honest answer has two parts: what the company says about how it holds your funds, and what went wrong once. On funds, 3Commas never holds them: the V2 guide says they “always sit on your own connected exchange, never with 3Commas.” On keys, it did fail once. The facts, from 3Commas’ own statements:

- **What happened.** On December 28, 2022, a post on Pastebin (since removed) claimed a hacker had accessed API data from 3Commas’ database. 3Commas says it learned of the incident from that post and, in its [notice](https://3commas.io/blog/notice-on-api-data-disclosure-incident) dated December 29, 2022, confirmed that some users’ API data was disclosed by a third party and that it may have been used to link exchange accounts to someone else’s or to make unauthorized trades.
- **How many.** Its [incident FAQ](https://3commas.io/blog/api-security-incident-faq), dated January 1, 2023, said “at least 100k Binance and Kucoin API keys and secrets have been exposed,” and that, going by the attackers’ sample data, the intrusion likely happened in October or November 2022.
- **What it did.** It asked Binance, KuCoin and other exchanges to revoke every key connected to 3Commas, told users “to reissue an API key they have currently connected to an exchange,” and said it was working with law enforcement. It had launched a “Sign Center,” a key store isolated from the rest of its systems, on November 16, 2022.
- **The cause.** 3Commas’ two pages describe it differently. The FAQ says criminal hackers “somehow obtained access to part of our database” and that the investigation was ongoing. The notice says the hacker’s post alleged that an employee had sold the data, that 3Commas found no evidence of any employee’s involvement, and that its internal investigations found no proof of compromised code or of breaches in its systems and servers. Both pages show an update date of May 21, 2026. We found no final statement of the cause from 3Commas.
- **Later changes.** A 2025 update on the notice page lists stricter encryption, isolated key environments, rate limiting and behavior checks, real-time checks against the exchange’s own key restrictions, alerts and activity logs, and external review of its engineering by third-party security auditors. Its security page does not mention audits.

[The Block](https://www.theblock.co/news/ecosystems/2022-12-28-binance-warns-about-3commas-api-leak-says-users-should-disable-keys-198295) reported on December 28, 2022 that a 3Commas spokesperson confirmed the data in the posted files was real, and that Changpeng Zhao, Binance’s chief executive at the time, urged anyone who had ever put an API key into 3Commas to disable it. The FAQ said the amount taken would be made public once the investigation was complete. We found no later figure from 3Commas, so we give none.

What this tells you: a respected bot platform can leak keys, and a key that cannot withdraw is the reason a leak is survivable. It is not proof that 3Commas is unsafe today, and it is not proof that it is safe.

## Is 3Commas legit?

It is a real company with a named legal entity, public co-founders, a help center and public pricing, and its pages document a working product: bots that trade on your exchange account by rules. We found nothing that supports calling it a scam, and we will not suggest one. We also did not find any financial licence or registration claim: 3Commas describes itself as software only, so it is not your broker or custodian.

“Legit” is also about the claims around bots. The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) issued a customer advisory on January 25, 2024, titled “AI Won’t Turn Trading Bots into Money Machines” ([press release 8854-24](https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/8854-24)); the [advisory page](https://www.cftc.gov/LearnAndProtect/AdvisoriesAndArticles/AITradingBots.html) now writes SI, for super intelligence, in place of AI. It warns that the technology cannot predict the future and that promises of unreasonably high returns are a red flag of fraud. A [joint alert](https://www.finra.org/investors/insights/artificial-intelligence-and-investment-fraud) from the SEC, NASAA and FINRA, from the same day, calls promised high returns with little or no risk a classic warning sign of fraud and tells you to check that you deal with a registered professional. Apply that to every bot, 3Commas included: no bot, however well built, removes market risk. The checklist is in [is AI trading legit?](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/is-ai-trading-legit)

## Where does 3Commas stop?

- **It is mid-move.** V1 closed on September 11, 2026 and V2 is new, so older tutorials, videos and reviews may not match what you see. The V2 guide says the V1 phone apps will be removed and V2 apps will come later.
- **Plans decide the markets.** Futures are not on every plan, so check the pricing answer below before you build a futures bot.
- **A crypto platform.** Its bots trade on the nine exchanges listed above, and all of it runs through your exchange keys. We found no stock trading on its pages.
- **Fixed bot types.** The AI assistant configures one of the bot types above. It is not a chat where you ask about a chart or a market.
- **Its demo is limited.** The demo guide says demo accounts trade the perpetual markets, so it is not a dress rehearsal for a spot grid.
- **Marketplace and copy features.** The V2 guides we read do not describe any, so we make no claim either way. V2 offers DCA bot presets in place of V1’s Strategy Gallery.

> **A quick test for any bot** Before you connect a key, ask: what can the key do, what happens to my open orders if the bot stops, and how can I test it without real money? 3Commas answers the first and the third well. The second changed in 2026: when V1 closed, orders already on the exchange stayed live but 3Commas no longer managed them.

## Who is 3Commas for, and who should look elsewhere?

**It suits you if** you already trade on one of the nine exchanges, you want DCA, grid or alert-driven bots running while you are away, you like to start on a demo account, and you are fine with a platform that is still settling after its rebuild.

**Look elsewhere if** you want a tool you can ask about a chart before you trade, you want to backtest an idea across a year of history and several markets without building a bot first, you trade stocks (we found none on its pages), or you do not want to hand an exchange key to anyone. Free and open-source routes are covered in [free AI trading bots](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/free-ai-trading-bot).

## What are the best 3Commas alternatives?

Sort them by what you want from a 3Commas alternative.

### You want the same kind of bot on another platform

**Cryptohopper** is the closest like-for-like: a cloud bot with a strategy marketplace, a paper-trading bot and a backtester in beta, on ten exchanges. We read it the same way in [our Cryptohopper review](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/cryptohopper-review) and set the two side by side in [3Commas vs Cryptohopper](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/3commas-vs-cryptohopper). **WunderTrading** is the partner 3Commas names for V2, so read its own pages for what it offers. For others, see the list of the [best AI trading bots](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/best-ai-trading-bots).

### You want bots inside the exchange

**Pionex** runs its bots inside its own exchange, so you deposit there instead of connecting a key. That trades the key risk for holding your money on the platform. We cover it in the Pionex section of [the 3Commas vs Cryptohopper comparison](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/3commas-vs-cryptohopper).

### You want to ask first, then trade

**Ethy** is an AI trading agent you ask before you trade. You ask about a chart and get a read on four timeframes at once (1D, 4H, 1H and 15m), describe an idea in plain words, and Ethy backtests that exact rule on up to 365 days of data across up to 10 markets, with every entry and exit marked. When you are ready it runs the rule on paper, with live prices and no money, or live. Automations run on Ethy’s servers around the clock; stop loss and take profit are native Hyperliquid orders that fire even when Ethy is closed.

Ethy is not a like-for-like swap. It trades Hyperliquid perps, which include crypto and trade.xyz’s stocks, commodities, indices and FX, and token swaps on Base, X Layer and Robinhood Chain. It has no marketplace, and it does not copy other traders’ wallets today. Your balance sits in a wallet that belongs to you, and you can export its key at any time; once you activate your agent, Ethy’s servers sign for it so trades and automations run without a pop-up. If you want a DCA bot on the exchange account you already use, 3Commas is the better fit. If you want to test an idea on past data first, and trade perps, Ethy is. More on that split is in [Ethy vs trading bots](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/ethy-vs-trading-bots).

> **Ask Ethy:** [Is BTC trending or ranging on the 4H right now?](https://agents.ethyai.app/chat?landing=blog&post=3commas-review&prompt=Is%20BTC%20trending%20or%20ranging%20on%20the%204H%20right%20now%3F)

## How do you decide whether to use 3Commas?

1. **Check the exchange** Is yours one of the nine? If not, the choice is made.
2. **Check the plan** Futures and the number of bots you can run depend on it. The pricing FAQ below has the details.
3. **Start on the demo account** It uses real prices and fake money. Watch a bot for a few weeks.
4. **Create the key safely** Trade only, no withdrawals, an IP allowlist, a sub-account if you can.
5. **Go live small** A size you could lose in full without changing your plans, and review it weekly.

**Test the idea before a bot runs it** Describe your rule in plain words. Ethy backtests it on up to a year of Hyperliquid data, marks every trade, and runs it on paper or live when you are ready. 500 free credits, no card. [Try it free](https://agents.ethyai.app/?landing=blog&post=3commas-review)

## Summary

- 3Commas, from 3C Trade Tech Ltd., automates crypto trades on your own exchange account through API keys; it holds no funds and says it has no withdrawal access.
- V1 closed on September 11, 2026 and V2, built with WunderTrading, is a new platform with a new account, so older reviews describe a product that no longer runs.
- In December 2022 a third party disclosed some users’ API keys: at least 100,000 Binance and KuCoin keys, per 3Commas’ own FAQ. Its later statements are on its notice page.
- Create keys with trade rights only, an IP allowlist and no withdrawals, and test on the demo account first.
- Alternatives: Cryptohopper for a like-for-like bot, Pionex for bots inside an exchange, and Ethy to ask about a chart, backtest and run an idea on Hyperliquid.

## Questions people ask

### Is 3Commas safe?

It never holds your funds, and its security page says it has no access to withdraw or transfer them. But in December 2022 a third party disclosed some users’ API keys, at least 100,000 Binance and KuCoin keys by 3Commas’ own FAQ. Use a key with trade rights only, no withdrawals and an IP allowlist, and review it often.

### Is 3Commas legit?

It is a real company with a named legal entity, public pricing and a documented product. We found no sourced reason to call it a scam, and no financial licence claim: it says it provides software only. Regulators warn that no bot can promise returns, so judge it as a tool, not a promise.

### What happened in the 3Commas hack?

On December 28, 2022 a post claimed a hacker had accessed 3Commas’ API data. 3Commas confirmed some users’ API data was disclosed by a third party, asked exchanges to revoke its keys and told users to reissue theirs. Its FAQ says hackers got into part of its database; its notice says it found no evidence of employee involvement or of breached systems. Both pages were last updated on May 21, 2026.

### Does 3Commas have a free demo account?

Its pricing page lists a demo account on every plan. The demo guide says it starts with $10,000 of virtual funds, resets on request, uses real-time prices, and trades the perpetual markets. You can have two demo accounts.

### What is the 3Commas DCA bot?

It is a bot that buys in steps rather than all at once, and V2 also uses it for indicator-based bots, such as RSI. We explain the idea in the DCA guide. Futures depend on your plan, so read the pricing answer before you set one up.

### How much does 3Commas cost?

On November 17, 2026 its pricing page listed Starter at $20 a month, Pro at $50 and Expert at $140, or $15, $38 and $105 a month billed yearly, with a free trial whose length the page does not state. Starter is spot only; futures start on Pro. Its AI page says the AI assistant is on the paid plans. For comparison, Ethy has a free plan with 500 credits, then $15, $59 or $179 a month.

## Sources

- [3Commas: notice on the API data disclosure incident (December 29, 2022, updated May 21, 2026)](https://3commas.io/blog/notice-on-api-data-disclosure-incident)
- [3Commas: API security incident FAQ (January 1, 2023, updated May 21, 2026)](https://3commas.io/blog/api-security-incident-faq)
- [3Commas: security](https://3commas.io/security)
- [3Commas: pricing](https://3commas.io/pricing)
- [3Commas: AI trading bot](https://3commas.io/ai-trading-bot)
- [3Commas: about](https://3commas.io/about)
- [3Commas help center: V2, everything you need to know](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16245835-3commas-v2-everything-you-need-to-know)
- [3Commas help center: moving from V1 to V2, features and bots](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16300161-moving-from-3commas-v1-to-3commas-v2-feature-bot-migration-guide)
- [3Commas help center: Terminal overview](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16281054-trading-terminal-overview)
- [3Commas help center: demo trading guide](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16281106-demo-trading-guide)
- [3Commas help center: connect your AI assistant to 3Commas (MCP)](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16527454-connect-your-ai-assistant-to-3commas-mcp)
- [3Commas help center: access your QuantPilot account after 3Commas sign-in ended (September 24, 2026)](https://help.3commas.io/en/articles/16394733-how-to-access-your-quantpilot-account-after-3commas-sign-in-ended)
- [The Block: Binance warns about 3Commas API leak (December 28, 2022)](https://www.theblock.co/news/ecosystems/2022-12-28-binance-warns-about-3commas-api-leak-says-users-should-disable-keys-198295)
- [CFTC: Customer Advisory on trading bots, issued as “AI Won’t Turn Trading Bots into Money Machines”](https://www.cftc.gov/LearnAndProtect/AdvisoriesAndArticles/AITradingBots.html)
- [CFTC: Press release 8854-24 on the AI scams advisory (January 25, 2024)](https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/8854-24)
- [FINRA, SEC and NASAA: Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Investment Fraud (January 25, 2024)](https://www.finra.org/investors/insights/artificial-intelligence-and-investment-fraud)
