# Ethy vs Claude for trading: the analyst and the agent

Claude reads long documents, reasons with care and writes the code you need. Ethy sits in the market: it reads the chart, tests the rule and watches the level. Here is what each one does for a trader, what Claude’s connectors and Claude Code add, where each one stops, and how to split the work. Claude details come from Anthropic’s own pages, read on November 15, 2026.

- URL: https://www.ethyai.app/blog/ethy-vs-claude
- Author: Ethy Team
- Published: November 15, 2026; updated: November 15, 2026
- Publisher: Ethy AI, https://www.ethyai.app/

**The short answer:** Claude is the stronger analyst: long documents, careful reasoning, code with Claude Code, and MCP connectors such as TradingView’s. Ethy is built for the trade itself: it reads the chart on four timeframes, tests a rule on past candles, watches your levels and can place orders with stops on Hyperliquid. A sensible split: Claude thinks, Ethy acts.

## Is Claude enough for trading, or do you also need Ethy?

Claude is enough if your edge lives in the reading. It will work through a 10-K, an earnings call transcript or a central bank statement in one sitting, reason carefully about what changed, and write the code to test what it found. Plenty of good trading needs nothing more from AI than that.

Claude stops at the edge of the market. It has no price feed of its own, no account to trade from, and nothing that watches a price after you close the chat unless you set it up or build it. Anthropic keeps Claude in Chrome and Claude Duet away from placing trades, on purpose. Ethy works on the other side of that line: it reads the chart from market data, backtests a rule, watches your levels, and can send the order, stops included, to Hyperliquid.

So the useful question isn’t which one is smarter. It’s which job you’re doing right now, and the table further down answers that job by job.

## What makes Claude strong for market research?

Four things, each documented by Anthropic as of November 15, 2026.

### It holds long documents

Claude’s current models, Fable 5.2, Opus 5.5, Sonnet 5.5 and Haiku 5.5, all have context windows of up to 1 million tokens (a token is a small piece of a word), so an annual report and the call that followed it fit in one conversation. Their training data stops in June 2026, so anything newer has to come from search or from files you add.

### It shows where answers come from

With web search on, Anthropic says “every response includes citations, so you can easily verify sources yourself.” Paid plans add Research, which works through many sources to answer a bigger question.

### It runs code and builds files on every plan

Claude can execute code in a sandbox and create files on Free, Pro, Max and Ultra. Anthropic’s own examples include “financial models in Excel with working formulas” and “advanced analyses on uploaded data.” Upload a CSV of daily candles and it can compute indicators, test a simple rule and chart what happened. Our guide to [backtesting a trading strategy](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/how-to-backtest-a-trading-strategy) covers the traps.

### It keeps your context

Projects are workspaces with their own chats, documents and instructions; Free accounts can have up to five. Memory is on by default on Free, Pro, Max and Ultra and carries context into new chats, and paid plans can also search past conversations. Put your trading rules in a project’s instructions and every chat inside it starts from them. On Pro, Max and Ultra, the Personal Finance beta links bank, card, loan and investment accounts through Plaid, and Anthropic is clear about its reach: it “can only read your accounts. It can’t move, manage, or invest your money.”

## What can Claude reach through MCP connectors?

MCP, the Model Context Protocol, is the open standard Anthropic created for connecting AI apps to tools and data. In Claude, a remote MCP server becomes a custom connector. Every plan can add custom connectors; Free is limited to one. Read Anthropic’s warning before you do: custom connectors reach services “that haven’t been verified by Anthropic,” and once connected, Claude “can access those services and take action in them.”

One connector built with traders in mind is TradingView’s official MCP server, in beta. It needs a TradingView Essential plan or above (trials don’t include it), and it gives Claude tools for:

- historical candles, up to 5,000 bars per request, from 1-minute to monthly;
- the screener, with fields such as P/E and market cap;
- news headlines and full stories for a symbol;
- economic, earnings and dividend calendars;
- analyst forecasts, financials, watchlists and alerts.

Two limits matter for trading. Through MCP, TradingView’s alert tool creates simple price alerts, and its docs say indicator-based alerts “are NOT supported yet.” None of its tools place orders. The full setup, step by step, is in [how to connect Claude to TradingView with MCP](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/claude-tradingview-mcp).

## Can you build your own trading tool with Claude Code and Skills?

Yes, if you are ready to own what you build. Claude Code is Anthropic’s agentic coding tool: it reads your codebase, edits files and runs commands, in the terminal, an IDE, a desktop app or the browser, and it comes with the paid plans. Skills are folders of instructions, scripts and resources that Claude loads when a task calls for them. Simple ones are plain Markdown, and they need code execution switched on.

Together they can [rebuild most of what a trading agent does](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/how-to-build-an-ai-trading-agent-for-onchain-markets), one piece at a time. Here is what each piece takes:

| Piece | Built with Claude Code | Ready in Ethy |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Market data | Find a source, then write and maintain the code that fetches and cleans it | Included for Hyperliquid perps, trade.xyz markets and spot tokens |
| Backtester | Any logic, on any data you bring; you check it for look-ahead bias (peeking at data from the future) and for costs | Rules written in plain English, tested on up to 365 days, every fill marked, and an optimizer that checks each setting on a held-out window |
| Order routing | An exchange or broker API, keys you store and protect, and error handling you write | Orders from the chat on Hyperliquid, with your take profit and stop loss sent as Hyperliquid trigger orders, plus spot swaps |
| Running it | A server or a schedule you maintain; Claude’s cloud scheduled tasks run hourly at most, and faster ones need your computer on | Automations on Ethy’s servers that keep going while you’re offline, live or on paper |
| Risk limits | Whatever you code and test yourself | A pause after a losing streak, on by default, plus a maximum daily loss, a maximum drawdown and a kill switch |
| A pre-trade checklist | A Skill in Markdown that Claude follows every time you ask | Your trading plan, which Ethy reads first in every chat |

Building teaches you a great deal and gives you full control, including over the bugs. If the goal is to trade rather than to run software, the ready-made route is shorter. Either way, keep exchange keys out of any chat, and run anything new on paper first.

## Claude or Ethy: which is better for each trading job?

| Job | Claude | Ethy | Verdict |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Read a 10-K or an earnings call | Keeps the whole document in view and answers questions about any part of it | Not what Ethy is built for | Claude |
| Know what’s on the calendar | Economic, earnings and dividend dates through TradingView’s connector | No economic or earnings calendar | Claude, with the connector |
| Check fundamentals such as P/E | TradingView’s financials and screener fields, or a filing you upload | No P/E data | Claude |
| Read the chart before a trade | From a screenshot (Anthropic notes that Claude’s coordinate and position readings are approximate) or from candles pulled through TradingView | Daily, 4H, 1H and 15m read together, with levels, divergences, Fibonacci, VWAP and a bias | Ethy on its markets; Claude with TradingView for the rest |
| Explain a move | Web search with citations, and Research for a deeper look | Web search with citations, with the price and the peers added without asking | Either |
| Test an idea | Python on data you upload, or a full backtester in Claude Code | Plain-English rules tested on Hyperliquid and spot candles for up to 365 days | Ethy for its markets; Claude for anything custom |
| Alert on an indicator | TradingView’s MCP alerts take simple price conditions only, for now | An RSI level, a 9/21 EMA cross or a MACD cross, as well as price levels and moves | Ethy |
| Place the order and its stops | Needs a broker’s connector, and Claude in Chrome is barred from executing trades | Orders on Hyperliquid, with take profit and stop loss held by the exchange | Ethy |
| Run a rule overnight | Cloud scheduled tasks at most hourly, with no order tools unless you add them | Automations that run on Ethy’s servers, with loss limits | Ethy |
| Keep your rules in view | Project instructions and memory | A trading plan in four parts that Ethy checks each idea against | Tie: Claude for broad context, Ethy for a check before the trade |
| Write Pine Script or a bot | Claude in chat, and Claude Code for whole projects | Not a coding tool | Claude |
| Price | Free; Pro $20 a month ($17 billed yearly); Max $100; Ultra $200 | A free plan, then paid plans (prices in the FAQ) | Claude, if one tool must do everything |

The pattern is plain enough. Claude wins every job that is about understanding: documents, dates, fundamentals, code. Ethy wins every job that has to happen in the market, at a level or at a candle close, with money on the line. The two jobs in the middle, explaining a move and keeping your rules, are close calls, and that is where using both pays off.

> **Ask Ethy:** [Alert me when NVDA’s 4H MACD crosses up.](https://agents.ethyai.app/chat?landing=blog&post=ethy-vs-claude&prompt=Alert%20me%20when%20NVDA%E2%80%99s%204H%20MACD%20crosses%20up.)

## What does Ethy add that Claude leaves to you?

Mostly the parts that touch money. Anthropic draws that line itself: its permissions guide for Claude in Chrome puts “executing financial trades or investment transactions” on the list of prohibited actions, and Claude Duet, its new proactive agent app, keeps trading securities off-limits even when you give approval. If you still want Claude sending orders through a broker’s connector, [can Claude trade for you?](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/can-claude-trade-for-you) covers the setups and the risks.

Ethy is built for exactly those parts:

- **An account from day one.** Every user gets a wallet at sign-up. Your balance lives in a wallet that belongs to you, and you can export its key at any time.
- **Orders with their exits attached.** Ask in the chat and Ethy places the perp or the swap; on a perp, your take profit and stop loss become Hyperliquid trigger orders, at the open or added later.
- **Rules that keep running.** Press Activate once and an automation trades whenever its rules are met, on Ethy’s servers, while you’re offline.
- **Limits you set once.** A pause after a losing streak is on by default; a maximum daily loss, a maximum drawdown, trading-hours windows and a kill switch are there when you want them.
- **Paper before money.** Paper mode runs on live prices and moves nothing, and one tap on “Go live” switches it to real money.
- **A plan that talks back.** Your rules for risk, markets, process and goals come up whenever an idea breaks one of them.

Ethy has limits of its own, too. There is no news feed and no calendar, and it carries no P/E data. Its markets stop at Hyperliquid perps (crypto and trade.xyz) and spot swaps on Base, X Layer and Robinhood Chain, with no options. Entries at a price are triggers rather than resting orders, so they fill at market when the level is hit. And there is no way to connect Claude to Ethy today: no API keys, no MCP server.

The whole app is described in [what Ethy AI is](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/what-is-ethy-ai), and if you work in ChatGPT instead, [Ethy vs ChatGPT](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/ethy-vs-chatgpt) covers that pairing. Two more comparisons weigh Ethy against [classic trading bots](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/ethy-vs-trading-bots) and against [trading by hand](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/ethy-vs-manual-trading).

## How do you split an earnings week between Claude and Ethy?

Here is one way the two fit around a single stock in an earnings week. Swap in your own market and your own rules.

1. **Monday, in Claude** Upload the last quarterly report and the call transcript. Ask what changed in guidance, margins and risks, and where in the documents each point comes from.
2. **Monday, Claude with TradingView** Ask for the report date, the consensus estimates and the economic releases due that week.
3. **Tuesday, in Ethy** Ask Ethy to read the stock on four timeframes and explain this week’s move, then check that the chart and the story agree.
4. **Wednesday, in Ethy** Backtest the entry you have in mind on past candles, and write the size and the stop into your trading plan.
5. **Before the report, in Ethy** Set an alert at your level, or run the setup on paper so nothing trades by surprise.
6. **After the report, in Claude** Paste what happened and ask what you would change next quarter. Keep the lessons in your Claude project.

**Earnings brief (attach the report and transcript in Claude)**

> I attached [company]’s latest quarterly report and its earnings call transcript. Summarize what changed since the previous quarter in guidance, margins and the risks management named, and point to where each claim appears in the documents. Then list three questions the next report has to answer. Do not tell me whether to buy or sell.

More prompts like this one, from chart reads to journal reviews, are in our [library of trading prompts](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/ai-trading-prompts).

> **Ask Ethy:** [Why did NVDA move this week, and where is support on the 4H?](https://agents.ethyai.app/chat?landing=blog&post=ethy-vs-claude&prompt=Why%20did%20NVDA%20move%20this%20week%2C%20and%20where%20is%20support%20on%20the%204H%3F)

**Let Claude read. Let Ethy watch.** Ethy reads the chart on four timeframes, tests your rule on past data and keeps an eye on the level, in plain English. Free to start, no card needed. [Start free](https://agents.ethyai.app/?landing=blog&post=ethy-vs-claude)

## Summary

- Claude is a strong analyst for traders: long documents, citations, code and files on every plan, projects and memory.
- Through MCP, TradingView’s official server gives Claude candles, screeners, news and calendars, with price-only alerts and no order tools.
- Claude Code and Skills can rebuild a trading tool piece by piece, if you are ready to own the data, the keys and the bugs.
- Ethy covers the jobs that happen in the market: four-timeframe chart reads, backtests on its candles, indicator alerts, orders with exits and automations with loss limits.
- Ethy has no news feed, calendar or P/E data, trades only its own markets, and can’t be connected to Claude.
- A sensible split: read and reason in Claude, then check, test and watch in Ethy.

## Questions people ask

### Is Claude good for trading?

For the thinking part, yes. Claude reads long filings, searches with citations, runs Python on your data and writes Pine Script or a whole bot with Claude Code. It has no market feed or trading account of its own, and Anthropic bars Claude in Chrome from executing trades. Use it to understand the market, and check every number on a live chart.

### Can Claude replace a trading bot?

Only if you build one. Claude Code can write a bot that calls an exchange API and runs on your own server, but then the data, the keys, the hosting and the bugs are yours. Claude’s cloud scheduled tasks run hourly at most and can’t hold a stop. A ready agent such as Ethy runs the rule for you and leaves the stop at the exchange.

### Can I connect Claude to Ethy?

No. Ethy offers no API keys or MCP server, so it can’t be added to Claude as a connector. Run the two side by side and carry the conclusion across by hand.

### How much do Claude and Ethy cost?

As of November 15, 2026, Claude is free, $20 a month for Pro ($17 a month billed yearly), $100 for Max and $200 for Ultra. Ethy is free to start with 500 credits; Core costs $15 a month, Pro $59 and Max $179, less billed yearly. Ethy also charges a fee on each trade that drops on higher plans, and Hyperliquid’s own fees and funding apply.

### Which Claude plan does a trader need?

Free already includes web search, code execution and files, memory, projects and one custom connector, such as TradingView’s. Pro adds Research, scheduled tasks, Claude Code and Claude in Chrome; Max and Ultra add usage. Start on Free and upgrade when a limit gets in your way.

### Does Claude work with TradingView?

Yes, through TradingView’s official MCP server, in beta, which needs a TradingView Essential plan or above. Claude can then pull candles, run the screener, read news and calendars and create simple price alerts. It can’t place trades through it.

## Sources

- [Claude: Plans and pricing](https://claude.com/pricing)
- [Claude Platform Docs: Models overview](https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/about-claude/models/overview)
- [Claude Platform Docs: Vision (limitations)](https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/build-with-claude/vision)
- [Claude Help Center: Enable and use web search](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/10684626-enabling-and-using-web-search)
- [Claude Help Center: Create and edit files with Claude](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/12111783-create-and-edit-files-with-claude)
- [Claude Help Center: What are projects?](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/9517075-what-are-projects)
- [Claude Help Center: Use chat search and memory](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/11817273-use-claude-s-chat-search-and-memory-to-build-on-previous-context)
- [Claude Help Center: Use Personal Finance in Claude](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/18185620-use-personal-finance-in-claude)
- [Claude Help Center: Get started with custom connectors using remote MCP](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/11175166-get-started-with-custom-connectors-using-remote-mcp)
- [Claude Help Center: What are skills?](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/12512176-what-are-skills)
- [Claude Code docs: Overview](https://code.claude.com/docs/en/overview)
- [Claude Help Center: Schedule recurring tasks](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/13854387-schedule-recurring-tasks-in-claude-cowork)
- [Claude Help Center: Claude in Chrome permissions guide](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/12902446-claude-in-chrome-permissions-guide)
- [Claude: Introducing Claude Duet (October 21, 2026)](https://claude.com/resources/articles/claude-duet)
- [TradingView: MCP Server documentation (beta)](https://www.tradingview.com/mcp/docs)
- [Hyperliquid Docs: Order types](https://hyperliquid.gitbook.io/hyperliquid-docs/trading/order-types)
- [Ethy AI: Plans](https://agents.ethyai.app/plans)
