# Minara AI review: what it trades, who holds the keys, and the alternatives

Minara calls itself your personal AI agent for trading. Here is what its own pages say it executes, on which venues, how it holds your funds, where it stops, and what to use if you want to test an idea before it trades.

- URL: https://www.ethyai.app/blog/minara-review
- Author: Ethy Team
- Published: November 17, 2026; updated: November 17, 2026
- Publisher: Ethy AI, https://www.ethyai.app/

**The short answer:** Minara is an AI trading agent built on DMind models. As of November 17, 2026, its docs say it trades perps on Hyperliquid and Lighter and spot on eight chains, and its Autopilot runs strategies without asking before each trade. Your funds sit in an onchain wallet whose key Minara operates and you can export.

## What is Minara, and who makes it?

Minara describes itself as “your personal AI agent for trading, anything, anywhere” and “the AI-native financial OS that evolves with you” ([minara.ai](https://minara.ai/), read November 17, 2026). Its docs call it “a purpose-built AI agent for digital finance” for research, signals, backtesting and execution across crypto, stocks and commodities ([About Minara](https://minara.ai/docs/readme.md)). You use it in a web app, a desktop app for macOS, or its phone apps.

The site footer reads “© 2026 Minara AI.” The AI underneath is DMind, which Minara’s docs describe as “an open-source research organization building large language models, benchmarks, datasets, and tools for Web3 and digital finance.” DMind’s models handle the finance work, and they are “paired with general-purpose models such as Claude and GPT” for everything else ([DMind](https://minara.ai/docs/technology/dmind.md)). Circle’s partner directory, updated March 3, 2026, also says Minara is powered by DMind and calls it one of DMind’s flagship applications ([Circle Alliance Directory](https://partners.circle.com/partner/minaraai)). Minara’s Terms of Use, last updated June 18, 2026, name the other party only as “Minara” and send disputes to arbitration seated in Singapore ([Terms of Use](https://minara.ai/doc/terms-of-use.pdf)).

This review reads Minara’s own pages, dated November 17, 2026. We did not trade with it, and we quote no star ratings or user reviews. If AI trading agents are new to you, start with [what an AI trading agent is](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/what-is-an-ai-trading-agent).

## What does Minara do well?

- **Research and trading in one chat.** You ask about a ticker, a wallet or a market event, and the same app can prepare the trade. Its Copilot reads price action, order-book depth, funding and open interest, and returns a long, short or neutral plan with an entry, a take-profit, a stop-loss and a short reason, after screening out setups with poor risk to reward ([Copilot docs](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/trading-copilot.md)).
- **Many venues and chains.** Perps trade on Hyperliquid or Lighter, two onchain exchanges, depending on the wallet you pick. Its asset page lists crypto, stock and commodity perps, with gold, silver and crude oil named ([assets](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/trade-assets.md)). Spot covers Solana, Ethereum, Base, BSC, Arbitrum, Optimism, Robinhood Chain and Arc, and it moves funds across chains for you ([assets and chains](https://minara.ai/docs/support/faq/trading/assets-and-chains.md)).
- **Autopilot with stops built in.** Autopilot opens and closes positions on its own, with a take-profit and stop-loss on every position, trailing stops, an optional drawdown limit on your starting equity and an automatic exit if equity falls to $5 ([Autopilot docs](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/trading-autopilot.md)).
- **A strategy builder with honest backtests.** Strategy Studio writes, backtests and tunes strategies in Pine Runtime, which it calls “Minara’s TypeScript DSL,” a small coding language ([Strategy Studio](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/strategy-studio.md)). Its FAQ warns about overfitting and suggests the Paper tab before real money ([backtesting FAQ](https://minara.ai/docs/support/faq/strategy-studio/backtesting.md)).
- **A marketplace with forward records.** Creators publish strategies, and each listing shows its backtest and a record since publication ([Strategy Marketplace](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/strategy-market.md)).
- **Watching wallets.** The desktop app can alert you to trades by onchain wallets on Solana, Ethereum, Base or BSC, and by public Hyperliquid or Lighter addresses ([monitoring docs](https://minara.ai/docs/automation/wallet-and-trader-monitoring.md)).
- **An exportable key.** You can export the private key of your wallets, spot and perps, and use them outside Minara.

For a trader who wants one app across crypto chains and two perp exchanges, that is a wide package.

## Does Minara place trades for you, and who holds the money?

Yes, it executes trades, and how much it does on its own depends on the mode.

- **Copilot asks.** It pre-fills an order and you confirm it with one click. The docs describe it as proposing “a trade for you to approve.”
- **Autopilot does not ask per trade.** The Terms say it executes trades “without requiring your manual approval for each individual trade,” once you pick a wallet and a strategy and complete an authorization flow. That mandate does not cover withdrawals to outside addresses, and you can revoke it. Minara’s overview says anything that moves your money waits for your approval ([how Minara works](https://minara.ai/docs/get-started/how-minara-works.md)), and its safety page explains that setting up an automation you explicitly authorized counts as that approval ([safety and approvals](https://minara.ai/docs/technology/safety-and-approvals.md)).
- **Automated plans ask by default.** Recurring buys, ladders and plans that mirror a wallet pause at “Waiting for your approval” unless you choose the Hands-off mode, which runs trades and transfers without asking ([automated plans](https://minara.ai/docs/automation/automated-trading-plans.md)).

On custody, the Terms say Minara provisions a “non-custodial Account Abstraction (‘AA’) smart-contract wallet” for you, “with the underlying signer infrastructure provided by Privy,” and that “Minara generates and operates the controlling key on your behalf.” They add: “until you export, you are relying on Minara’s security practices and operational integrity.” Minara also says it does not lend or rehypothecate your funds, meaning it does not reuse them as collateral.

Its docs describe the wallet in two ways. The wallet basics FAQ says it is built on ERC-4337 and “powered by Privy” ([wallet basics](https://minara.ai/docs/support/faq/wallet-and-security/wallet-basics.md)). The wallet security page says it is built on EIP-7702, with signing keys protected by AWS Key Management Service, and names no outside provider ([wallet security](https://minara.ai/docs/technology/wallet-security.md)). Both pages agree on what matters to you: your assets sit at your own onchain address, Minara holds a key that can trade them, and you can export that key. The same page says SlowMist, a blockchain security firm, audited Minara from July 30 to August 19, 2025, with a “Passed” result.

> **What this means** Minara is not a broker holding your money in its own account, and it is not a read-only research tool either. Once Autopilot or a Hands-off plan is on, software you authorized trades your wallet by itself. Size it as if it can lose what you put in, because its Terms say it can.

## Where does Minara stop?

- **Automation needs the desktop app running.** Alerts, scheduled briefs, wallet monitoring and automated plans work only in the desktop app, and the docs say runs can be delayed or missed while it is closed or offline. Autopilot is a separate feature.
- **Autopilot has entry rules.** It needs at least $500 of available funds, uses cross margin only, and takes USDC deposits on Arbitrum. You cannot cancel the take-profit and stop-loss orders it manages while it is active.
- **Stopping a strategy closes it.** A deployed Strategy Studio strategy cannot be paused with its positions kept: “Stopping it closes every position it holds” ([deploying FAQ](https://minara.ai/docs/support/faq/strategy-studio/deploying-and-live-trading.md)).
- **Custom strategies are code.** The AI helps you write Pine Runtime, but what runs is code, and the backtesting FAQ does not say how far back the history goes.
- **Prediction markets are signals.** Its prediction markets page says “Only Hyperliquid Outcome markets are available” and that you submit every order yourself ([prediction markets](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/prediction-markets.md)), while its overview speaks of Polymarket coverage. Read the page for the feature you plan to use.
- **The Terms put the risk on you.** Minara says it is not liable for Autopilot losses as long as Autopilot stayed within your authorization and the strategy’s settings.

None of this is unusual for a tool that trades by itself. It is the part a sales page tends to skip, so read it before you fund a wallet. Regulators make the same point about every bot: the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission warns that AI cannot predict the future and that promises of high returns are a red flag ([CFTC advisory](https://www.cftc.gov/LearnAndProtect/AdvisoriesAndArticles/AITradingBots.html)). Our checklist is in [is AI trading legit?](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/is-ai-trading-legit)

## Who is Minara for, and who should look elsewhere?

### Minara suits you if

- you trade crypto on several chains and want research, swaps and perps in one app;
- you want perps on both Hyperliquid and Lighter;
- you are happy to write or edit strategy code with an AI helper, or to run a creator’s strategy from its marketplace;
- you keep a desktop computer running for alerts and automated plans.

### Look elsewhere if

- you want to describe a rule in plain English and see the exact rules before anything runs, without code;
- you want alerts and automations that keep running with your computer off;
- you want to start Autopilot-style automation with less than $500;
- you only want stocks in a regular brokerage account.

## What are the alternatives to Minara?

Pick by what you want the agent to do.

| If you want | Look at | What to know |
| --- | --- | --- |
| An AI agent that builds and runs Hyperliquid strategies, and can copy traders | Senpi | Strategies run in their own sub-wallets. See [Senpi and its alternatives](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/senpi-alternatives). |
| Bots driven by your own TradingView alerts, on many crypto exchanges | WunderTrading | Signal, DCA and grid bots through API keys. See our [WunderTrading review](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/wundertrading-review). |
| Classic DCA and grid bots on a centralized exchange | 3Commas | Rebuilt as V2 in 2026. See our [3Commas review](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/3commas-review). |
| An agent inside your stock broker | Robinhood Agents | Trades in a separate account you fund. See [Robinhood Agents and the alternatives](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/robinhood-agents-alternatives). |
| To describe a rule, test it, run it on paper, then trade it | Ethy | An AI trading agent you ask before you trade, on Hyperliquid and three spot chains. |

Ethy is the closest fit if testing comes first. You write the rule in plain English, for example “go long ETH on the 4H when price closes above the last swing high in a downtrend, with a stop below the last swing low,” and Ethy shows you the rules it built so you can check them before a backtest. Conditions read market structure directly (swings, breaks of structure, liquidity sweeps, fair value gaps, retests) next to 22 indicators. You backtest up to 365 days on up to 10 markets, with every entry and exit marked, then run it in paper mode on live prices with no money, then live.

Ethy trades Hyperliquid perps: crypto, plus stocks, indices, commodities and currencies on trade.xyz, from one USDC balance, and it swaps tokens on Base, X Layer and Robinhood Chain. Automations run on Ethy’s servers, so they keep going with your laptop closed, and stop loss and take profit are native Hyperliquid orders. Each automation can carry a trailing stop, a maximum daily loss and a maximum drawdown in dollars, and a pause after 10 losing trades in a row, on by default. Your balance sits in a wallet that belongs to you, you can export its key at any time, and Ethy is non-custodial; once you activate the agent, its servers sign trades for that wallet.

Where Minara goes further: Lighter, more spot chains, prediction-market signals, wallet mirroring and a marketplace of creators’ strategies. Ethy does not copy wallets, has no user marketplace (its Top Strategies are a shelf Ethy curates), and does not connect to Lighter. For the wider list, see the [best AI trading bots](https://www.ethyai.app/blog/best-ai-trading-bots).

> **Ask Ethy:** [Backtest a long on ETH 4H when price closes above the last swing high in a downtrend, stop below the last swing low.](https://agents.ethyai.app/chat?landing=blog&post=minara-review&prompt=Backtest%20a%20long%20on%20ETH%204H%20when%20price%20closes%20above%20the%20last%20swing%20high%20in%20a%20downtrend%2C%20stop%20below%20the%20last%20swing%20low.)

## Can you move a Minara strategy to Ethy?

Not by importing it. Ethy does not read Pine Runtime or any other strategy code. What carries over is the idea. If your Minara strategy goes long on a break of structure with a stop behind the last swing, you describe that in plain English, and Ethy rebuilds it from its own conditions and shows you the rules. Ethy even has a ready-made template for that case, “Structure Shift Reversal,” a change-of-character strategy.

Two honest limits. A cross-sectional strategy that ranks a basket of assets will not map one to one, because one Ethy automation trades up to 10 assets with one rule. And a strategy that mirrors a wallet has no Ethy equivalent today. Expect the results of a rebuilt rule to differ from the original.

1. **Write the rule down** Entry, stop, target, market and time frame, in one or two sentences.
2. **Describe it to Ethy** Type it in plain English and read the rules Ethy shows back. Fix anything that is not what you meant.
3. **Backtest it** Run it on up to 365 days of past prices. A backtest is an estimate on past data, not a promise.
4. **Run it on paper** Paper mode uses live prices and moves no money.
5. **Go live with limits** Set a stop-loss, a maximum daily loss and the losing-streak pause before you press Activate.

**Test the idea before it trades** Describe a rule in plain English, check the rules Ethy built, backtest it on up to a year of Hyperliquid data and run it on paper. 500 free credits, no card. [Try it free](https://agents.ethyai.app/?landing=blog&post=minara-review)

## Summary

- Minara is an AI trading agent from Minara AI, built on DMind models paired with Claude and GPT, with web, desktop and phone apps.
- Per its docs on November 17, 2026, it trades perps on Hyperliquid and Lighter, including stock and commodity perps, and spot on eight chains.
- Copilot asks before each trade; Autopilot trades without per-trade approval once you authorize it; automated plans ask unless you choose Hands-off.
- Your funds sit in an onchain smart-contract wallet whose controlling key Minara operates; you can export it, and its Terms say you rely on Minara’s security until you do.
- Ethy is the alternative for testing first: plain-English rules you can check, backtests up to 365 days, paper mode, then live with loss limits.

## Questions people ask

### Is Minara legit?

Minara is a real product with public docs, Terms of Use updated June 18, 2026, and a SlowMist audit from 2025 that its docs report as passed. Its pages name the company only as Minara AI. We did not test the software or check any registration, and its Terms say AI output is not investment advice.

### Is Minara non-custodial?

Minara calls its wallet non-custodial: your assets sit at your own onchain address, and you can export the key. Its Terms also say Minara generates and operates the controlling key and has technical access to the signing keys, so until you export, you rely on its security.

### Does Minara trade for you?

Yes. Copilot prepares an order and you confirm it. Autopilot, once authorized for a wallet and a strategy, executes trades without asking before each one. Automated plans in the desktop app ask by default, unless you choose the Hands-off mode.

### Can Minara copy other traders?

Its desktop app can alert you to trades by public Hyperliquid or Lighter addresses and onchain wallets, and an automated plan can mirror a wallet’s trades with a fixed amount per trade and a daily cap. Plans need the desktop app running and can lag the original trade.

### How much does Minara cost?

Its credits page, read November 17, 2026, lists Free at $0 with 300 credits, Lite at $19 a month, Starter at $49 and Pro at $199, with annual billing offered. Trades are charged separately as trading fees, which its fees page lists by venue and mode. For comparison, Ethy has a free plan with 500 credits, then $15, $59 or $179 a month.

### What is a good Minara alternative?

Senpi if you want another Hyperliquid AI agent that can copy traders, WunderTrading or 3Commas for classic crypto bots, Robinhood Agents for stocks in a broker. Ethy if you want to describe a rule in plain English, backtest it up to 365 days and run it on paper before it trades.

## Sources

- [Minara: home page (read November 17, 2026)](https://minara.ai/)
- [Minara docs: About Minara](https://minara.ai/docs/readme.md)
- [Minara docs: How Minara works](https://minara.ai/docs/get-started/how-minara-works.md)
- [Minara docs: AI trading copilot](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/trading-copilot.md)
- [Minara docs: Autopilot](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/trading-autopilot.md)
- [Minara docs: Strategy Studio](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/strategy-studio.md)
- [Minara docs: Strategy Studio backtesting FAQ](https://minara.ai/docs/support/faq/strategy-studio/backtesting.md)
- [Minara docs: deploying and live trading FAQ](https://minara.ai/docs/support/faq/strategy-studio/deploying-and-live-trading.md)
- [Minara docs: Strategy Marketplace](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/strategy-market.md)
- [Minara docs: automated trading plans](https://minara.ai/docs/automation/automated-trading-plans.md)
- [Minara docs: wallet and trader monitoring](https://minara.ai/docs/automation/wallet-and-trader-monitoring.md)
- [Minara docs: assets and chains FAQ](https://minara.ai/docs/support/faq/trading/assets-and-chains.md)
- [Minara docs: assets](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/trade-assets.md)
- [Minara docs: prediction markets](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/prediction-markets.md)
- [Minara docs: safety and approvals](https://minara.ai/docs/technology/safety-and-approvals.md)
- [Minara docs: wallet security](https://minara.ai/docs/technology/wallet-security.md)
- [Minara docs: wallet and balance FAQ](https://minara.ai/docs/support/faq/wallet-and-security/wallet-basics.md)
- [Minara docs: DMind](https://minara.ai/docs/technology/dmind.md)
- [Minara docs: credits and plans](https://minara.ai/docs/reference/credits.md)
- [Minara docs: trading fees](https://minara.ai/docs/trade/trading-fees.md)
- [Minara: Terms of Use (last updated June 18, 2026)](https://minara.ai/doc/terms-of-use.pdf)
- [Circle Alliance Directory: Minara.ai (updated March 3, 2026)](https://partners.circle.com/partner/minaraai)
- [CFTC: Customer Advisory on AI trading bots](https://www.cftc.gov/LearnAndProtect/AdvisoriesAndArticles/AITradingBots.html)
