Some AI trading bots run machine-learning signals, some are agents you chat with, and many are rule bots with AI on the label. Here is what 12 popular tools actually do, what they cost in November 2026, where your money sits, and how to try one without getting burned.
Updated November 16, 2026
26
min to read
The short answer
The best AI trading bot depends on what you trade and how much you want automated. For crypto, 3Commas, Cryptohopper, Bitsgap, Coinrule and Webot, formerly Pionex.US, run rule bots with AI helpers. For stocks, Trade Ideas, TrendSpider, Composer and TradersPost. To talk to an agent, Robinhood Agents, Senpi and Ethy. Practice on paper first.
Three very different things are sold under the same two letters. Knowing which one you’re looking at tells you what can go wrong.
| Kind of AI | What it does | Examples in this list | What to ask |
|---|---|---|---|
| Machine-learning signals | A model trained on past market data scores stocks, spots setups or picks trades. You get a signal or a score, and you or a rule acts on it. | Trade Ideas’ Holly; TrendSpider’s ML Quant Lab; Freqtrade’s FreqAI, for coders | Are the published results live trades or simulations? Was the model checked on data it never saw? |
| A language model you talk to | A large language model (LLM), the kind of AI behind ChatGPT and Claude, reads your request in plain English, explains, writes the rule and, if it has the tools, places the order. | Robinhood Agents, Senpi and Ethy; the chat builders in 3Commas, Bitsgap, Coinrule and Composer | What can it do without asking me? How is a strategy tested before it trades? |
| Rules with AI on the label | A fixed rule, such as a grid of buy and sell orders or a weekly buy, runs exactly as set. The AI, if any, suggests the settings or picks among rules. | Grid and DCA bots with AI-suggested settings; Cryptohopper’s Algorithm Intelligence | What exactly does the AI do here? Can I see and change the rule? |
None of the three is better by default. A fixed rule is predictable and easy to backtest, and it keeps going when the market stops suiting it. A model’s signal can catch patterns a person would miss, then fade when markets change. The research on how far such signals go is in our guide to whether AI can predict the stock market. A language model is the easiest to use and the hardest to pin down, because it can misread an instruction or state a wrong number with confidence. Most tools now mix them: a language model writes a rule, and plain code runs it.
So the question that matters is what sends the order, and what limits it. For the fuller picture of what a trading bot actually is, kinds, keys and failure modes, see what a trading bot is. If the difference between a bot, a chatbot and an agent is new to you, start with what an AI trading agent is, or for the wider landscape they all sit inside, what AI trading is.
We compared the tools below on public information: each company’s own website, help center and pricing page, read on November 15, 2026. We didn’t trade with them, and prices change, so check the date next to each one. We make one of the tools, Ethy, and say so where it appears. The list is grouped by type and numbered for reference, not ranked. These are the eight questions we asked of every tool:
These five automate crypto trading. Four connect to an exchange account you already have; the fifth is an exchange with the bots built in. Two bot types come up in all of them: a DCA bot buys in steps as the price falls (DCA stands for dollar-cost averaging), and a grid bot places a ladder of buy and sell orders across a price range.
3Commas, around since 2017, runs DCA, grid and signal bots, the last fed by alerts from TradingView, plus a trading terminal, on nine exchanges including Binance, Coinbase, Kraken, OKX, Bybit and Hyperliquid, an onchain exchange for crypto futures. Its AI Assistant takes a strategy you describe “in plain language” and “configures, backtests, and launches the bot” (3Commas). It also offers an MCP connection, the open standard that lets AI apps such as Claude use outside tools, so an assistant can work with your 3Commas account.
Cryptohopper, founded in 2017 in the Netherlands, runs its bots in the cloud, so nothing has to stay open on your computer. You can design strategies, buy strategies and signals on its marketplace, and run arbitrage bots on the top plan, on ten exchanges including Binance, Coinbase Advanced, Kraken, KuCoin and OKX. Its “Algorithm Intelligence” backtests several strategies at once and switches to whichever has been doing best (Cryptohopper), and an AI strategy designer comes with the Hero plan.
Bitsgap, which began as a project in 2016, runs grid, DCA and buy-the-dip bots on spot markets, and DCA and grid bots on futures with up to 10x leverage, across 17 exchanges, from Binance, Coinbase and Kraken to Hyperliquid. Its AI Chat answers questions such as which strategies worked and “shows the strategy, its backtest and the settings” before you tap Launch. A separate AI Assistant picks a preset for your balance and risk preference.
Coinrule, launched in 2019 and backed by Y Combinator, is built around rules you can read, such as: if the RSI is below 30, buy. Its AI turns plain English, Python or Pine Script, TradingView’s scripting language, into a rule, and an optimizer suggests changes without applying them. Its own help center sums it up: “AI helps develop the strategy, while the configured rules govern execution” (Coinrule). It lists more than 25 exchanges and brokers, Hyperliquid among them, and its help center documents US stocks and ETFs through brokers such as Alpaca, Webull, Public and E*TRADE. Claude, ChatGPT and Grok can connect to it through MCP.
Pionex is an exchange with trading bots built in, and its US platform, Pionex.US, now goes by Webot. Instead of connecting a bot to an exchange with keys, you deposit on Webot and start a grid, DCA or rebalancing bot in its own app, from 11 bot types and with no subscription (Webot). The “AI” is narrow: grid bots can start with AI-recommended settings, and Webot’s user agreement says its bots follow “predetermined algorithmic or mathematical formulas” with no discretion of their own.
Stock tools split the job differently. One finds trades, one tests them on charts, one runs a whole strategy as a broker, and one only carries orders to the broker you already use.
Trade Ideas has made scanners for US stocks and ETFs since 2002. Its AI, Holly, backtests more than 60 strategies every night and optimizes each one; during the session, “Holly AI Signals fire during the trading day with a symbol, an entry and a stop” (Trade Ideas). An AI Assistant turns a scan you describe in plain English into a live scanner window. On the paid plans, its Brokerage Plus module sends orders through Interactive Brokers, E*TRADE, TradeStation or Alpaca, and Premium adds automatic trading of your own scan strategies.
TrendSpider, founded in 2016, is a charting and research platform for stocks, ETFs, futures, crypto and currencies. Its AI comes in three forms: Sidekick, a chat assistant that runs on language models from several vendors (help center); plain-English conditions that it turns into scripts; and a Quant Model Lab where you train models such as random forests on your own strategy, which its help center says “will not print you money directly” (TrendSpider). Its automatic trendlines and candlestick detection are rule-based math. Strategy Bots send orders to a broker or exchange through webhooks, automatic messages one app sends another, using services such as TradersPost or SignalStack (bots).
Composer, started in 2020 and part of SoFi since June 2026, lets you build a rule-based strategy, which it calls a symphony, by describing it to its AI or in a visual editor. You backtest it, and Composer trades and rebalances it for you. The AI writes rules but doesn’t trade on a hunch: “Composer AI doesn’t make trading decisions for you,” its FAQ says, and it names Claude by Anthropic and GPT by OpenAI as the models it uses. You review and confirm every symphony before it runs. Composer is the broker too: Composer Securities LLC is registered with the SEC as a broker-dealer and is a member of FINRA and SIPC. Our Composer alternatives guide compares it with Coinrule, TrendSpider, Robinhood Agents and Ethy in more depth.
TradersPost, founded in 2021, takes alerts from TradingView, TrendSpider or your own code, an AI agent included, and turns them into orders at your broker: Robinhood, Interactive Brokers, Webull, E*TRADE, tastytrade, Public, TradeStation and Alpaca for stocks, Tradovate and NinjaTrader for futures, and Coinbase, Kraken and Binance for crypto (FAQ). It has no AI and says so: it “does not provide alerts, signals, research, analysis, or trading advice of any kind.”
The newest group isn’t a bot you configure but an agent you talk to. You say what you want in plain English, and a language model with trading tools does the research, builds the rule or places the order. Three are worth knowing, each in a different place.
Robinhood Agents lets you create an AI agent in the Robinhood app, running on a large language model from a third-party provider. It researches, analyzes your portfolio and trades stocks, options and crypto in a separate agentic account that you fund. Trade approvals are on by default for the built-in agent, so it proposes and you place the order, and Robinhood warns that “AI agents can make errors, misinterpret instructions, act on incomplete or outdated information” (Robinhood). Chat is paid in AI tokens from a prepaid balance. As of November 15, 2026, its help center says it is “still rolling out,” and the full experience is only in the mobile app. Best for: an agent at the broker you already use. How it works, what it costs and its rivals are in Robinhood Agents and the alternatives.
Senpi turns a plain-English idea into a strategy on Hyperliquid, where it trades perpetual futures, or perps: contracts that track a price, with no expiry, that you can trade long or short, often with leverage. Each strategy runs in its own sub-wallet, with stops and loss limits enforced by its engine. It can also follow wallets its tracker surfaces, and you can use it from Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants. Senpi says its agent can trade but never withdraw. It has no paper mode: a small live run is its test. Plans on its pricing page on November 15, 2026: a free trial, then $50, $100 or $200 a month. Best for: Hyperliquid traders who want an agent to build and run strategies. The full review is in Senpi alternatives.
Ethy is an AI trading agent, and it is ours, so weigh this entry with that in mind. It trades perps on Hyperliquid: crypto on the main exchange, plus stocks such as NVDA and AAPL, indices, gold, oil and currencies on trade.xyz, an exchange built on Hyperliquid, all from one USDC balance (USDC is a dollar stablecoin). It also swaps tokens on Base, X Layer and Robinhood Chain.
You chat with it. It reads a chart on four timeframes at once (1D, 4H, 1H and 15m), finds out why a market moved and cites its sources, and turns a rule you write in plain words into one you can check before anything runs. Then it backtests that exact rule on up to 365 days of past data and up to 10 markets in one run, with every entry and exit on the chart and the result next to buy and hold. You run the rule on paper, with live prices and no money, or live. Alerts on price levels and indicators arrive in the app or on Telegram, and your written trading plan is checked in every chat. How that differs from asking ChatGPT is covered in Ethy vs ChatGPT, and how it works as an AI trading bot on its own page.
Public and Interactive Brokers have launched agents for stock investors as well; they are compared in the Robinhood article linked above and in our guide to agentic trading.
| Tool | Kind of AI | Markets | Where your money sits | Testing | Price, Nov 15, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3Commas | A chat assistant that sets up bots; grids with AI-suggested settings | Crypto spot and futures, 9 exchanges | Your exchange account, through a trade-only key | Backtests; demo account | $20 to $140 a month; $15 to $105 billed yearly |
| Cryptohopper | Switches to the strategy with the best recent backtest; AI designer on Hero | Crypto, 10 exchanges | Your exchange account, by login or key | Backtester (limits vary); paper bot | $29 to $129 a month; $24.16 to $107.50 billed yearly |
| Bitsgap | A chat that proposes bots with their backtest | Crypto spot and futures, 17 exchanges | Your exchange account, through a trade-only key | Backtests of 30 to 365 days; demo | Free plan; $29 to $149 a month; $23 to $119 billed yearly |
| Coinrule | AI writes the rule; the rule trades | Crypto and some US stocks and ETFs, across 25+ exchanges and brokers | Your exchange or broker account; no withdrawal keys | Backtests; demo exchange | Free plan; from $29.99 a month billed yearly |
| Webot (Pionex.US) | Rule bots with AI-suggested settings | Spot crypto | On the exchange, which holds it | No backtest tool or paper mode found | No subscription; 0.1% maker, 0.5% taker |
| Trade Ideas | Machine-learning signals (Holly); a scan builder | US stocks and ETFs | Your broker account | 60-day backtests on Premium; simulator | Free, delayed data; $127 or $254 a month; $89 or $178 billed yearly |
| TrendSpider | A chat assistant; machine-learning models you train | Stocks, ETFs, futures, crypto, currencies | Your broker or exchange, through webhooks or links | Backtests; forward testing | Trial from $19; sale prices in November |
| Composer | Language models write rule-based strategies | US stocks and ETFs | Composer Securities, its own broker-dealer | Unlimited backtests; Watch mode | Free; $10 or $40 a month; $32 billed yearly |
| TradersPost | None: it carries your alerts to your broker | US stocks, futures, crypto spot; options in beta | Your broker account | No backtester; paper broker | $49 to $299 a month after a free trial |
| Robinhood Agents | An AI agent you chat with | Stocks, options and crypto | A separate Robinhood account you fund | None described in its help pages | AI tokens from a prepaid balance |
| Senpi | An AI agent you chat with | Hyperliquid perps: crypto and trade.xyz | Your wallet; Senpi says its agent can’t withdraw | No paper mode; a small live run | Free trial; $50 to $200 a month |
| Ethy | An AI agent you chat with, with backtests | Hyperliquid perps: crypto and trade.xyz; token swaps | A wallet that belongs to you; Ethy signs for it from its servers | Backtests up to 365 days; paper mode | Free plan; $15, $59 or $179 a month |
Two rows answer a different question from the rest. TradersPost has no AI at all: it is the pipe that turns someone else’s signal into an order. And the three agents decide much more by themselves than the bots above them do, which is why their limits and tests matter more.
No tool wins every category, so here are the strongest fits for five kinds of trader, with the reason for each.
Pick a tool with a free tier and a practice mode, so your first mistakes cost nothing; our guide to a free AI trading bot covers what free really gets you. For crypto, Bitsgap (a free plan, demo bots and a backtest shown before you launch) and Coinrule (a free plan, rules you can read, a demo exchange). Webot is the simplest to set up, but the exchange holds your money. For stocks, Composer: a free plan, an AI that writes rules you confirm, and a Watch mode on simulated money. If writing a trading rule is new to you, start with our guide to algorithmic trading for beginners.
Trade Ideas if you day-trade and want scanners and intraday ideas; TrendSpider if your trading starts from the chart; Composer for rule sets that rebalance themselves; TradersPost to automate your signals at the broker you already use; Robinhood Agents for an agent inside Robinhood. What AI can and can’t do for each job, from screening to journaling, is in our guide to AI stock trading. For robo-advisors and other AI tools for long-term investors, see our guide to AI investing.
3Commas, Cryptohopper and Bitsgap for many bot types across many exchanges, and Coinrule for readable rules. All four reach your exchange with keys you control, and all four say they never need withdrawal rights. We compare them with Ethy, job by job, in Ethy vs trading bots.
Ethy and Senpi both trade Hyperliquid’s crypto perps and the stock, index and commodity perps on trade.xyz: Ethy if you want to backtest and paper-trade first, Senpi if you want to follow wallets or work from Claude or ChatGPT. 3Commas, Bitsgap and Coinrule also connect to Hyperliquid. For the tools built only for Hyperliquid, Telegram bots and copy tools included, see our list of the best Hyperliquid trading bots.
Freqtrade is a free, open-source crypto bot in Python, with backtesting, a dry-run mode and FreqAI, a module for training machine-learning models that “generate market forecasts”; its docs tell you to use it at your own risk. TradersPost takes webhooks from your own code to your broker. 3Commas and Coinrule let Claude and other AI apps work with your account over MCP, and Composer offers an API on its Pro plan and has written about an MCP server for it. How people wire ChatGPT to a broker, and where it stops, is in can ChatGPT trade for you?
The tools in this list share some habits: a price you can read before you sign up, a company you can look up, and results labeled as simulations. Be wary of any bot that:
Even an established tool can leak keys, as 3Commas’ 2022 incident showed, which is why a key should be able to trade and nothing more. The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission summed up the larger point in the title of a 2024 customer advisory: “AI Won’t Turn Trading Bots into Money Machines.” For the scam patterns regulators describe, and how to check whether a firm is registered, read is AI trading legit?
Run the bot with simulated money on live prices for a few weeks before real money. Most tools in this list have a paper or demo mode; where one doesn’t, the smallest live size is your test. The exchanges’ demo modes are compared in our guide to paper trading crypto.
Look at the worst drawdown, the longest losing streak and the comparison with simply holding, then check the settings on months they weren’t tuned on. Our backtesting guide shows how.
Create an API key that can trade and nothing else: withdrawals off, and an IP allowlist if your exchange offers one, so the key only works from the bot’s servers. Better still, use a sub-account that holds only what the bot may trade.
A size you could lose in full without changing your plans. Add money only after the live results look like the backtest.
A stop loss that rests at the exchange, a daily loss limit and a kill switch you have tried once: stop the bot and close its positions in one step.
Compare live results with the backtest. When they drift apart, stop the bot and find out why before you restart it.
Yes, with limits. Bitsgap and Coinrule have free plans, Trade Ideas has a free account on delayed data, Composer’s free plan automates one strategy, and Ethy’s free plan comes with 500 credits and no card. Webot charges no subscription; its bots cost nothing beyond trading fees. Freqtrade is free, open-source software you run yourself. Free tiers cap what you can automate, so check the limits before you build on one.
One with a free tier and a practice mode, so early mistakes cost nothing. For crypto, Bitsgap and Coinrule both offer free plans and demo accounts, and Coinrule’s if-then rules are easy to read. For stocks, Composer’s free plan lets an AI write a rule you confirm, with a Watch mode on simulated money. Whatever you pick, start on paper and keep your first real size small.
As software, yes: they follow rules and place orders faster and more steadily than a person. Whether they make money depends on the strategy, the market and your costs, and a strategy that shone in a backtest can still lose money live. No bot can promise profits. Judge one by its tested results, its worst drawdown and its live record, not by screenshots.
It depends on how you trade. 3Commas, Cryptohopper and Bitsgap run many bot types across many exchanges, each with an AI helper; Coinrule builds readable if-then rules; Webot puts the bots inside the exchange. For Hyperliquid perps, Ethy and Senpi are AI agents built for that exchange. Compare keys, testing and price in the table above before you choose.
For day traders who want scanners and trade ideas, Trade Ideas and its Holly AI. For chart-based setups, TrendSpider. For a rule set that trades and rebalances itself, Composer, which is also the broker. To send your own alerts to your broker, TradersPost. For an agent inside your broker, Robinhood Agents. To trade stock perps around the clock, Ethy on trade.xyz.
Partly. They can explain a strategy, write a bot’s code and read a chart screenshot, but they place orders only through a connector. 3Commas, Coinrule and Robinhood’s Trading MCP let Claude and other AI apps work with your account, and Composer offers an MCP server on its Pro plan. Keep approvals on and limits tight, because a chat assistant can misread an instruction.
In November 2026, most paid plans in this list cost $10 to $150 a month. The priciest tiers run $200 to $300 a month, such as Senpi’s Quant, Trade Ideas’ Premium and TradersPost’s Premium, and Coinrule’s Pro is $749 a month billed yearly. Most give about 15% to 35% off for paying yearly. Webot charges trading fees instead of a subscription, and Robinhood Agents bills AI tokens from a prepaid balance.
Trading involves risk, including the loss of your money. Ethy AI is a research and trading tool and does not give investment advice or recommendations. Backtests are simulations on historical data and do not predict future results.
Deploy your AI trading agent in one click.
