Tools and comparisons

Ethy vs trading bots like 3Commas, Cryptohopper and Pionex: which should you use?

Classic bots run a rule you already know, on the exchange you already use, and they do it well and often cheaply. Ethy starts earlier: it reads the market, tests an idea you describe in one sentence and runs it with stops on Hyperliquid. Here is what each does, checked on their own pages on November 15, 2026, and how to choose.

[

November 15, 2026

]
•
[

14

 

min to read

]

The short answer

Pick a classic bot when you already know your rule and trade on a big exchange: 3Commas, Cryptohopper, Bitsgap, Coinrule and Pionex run DCA, grid and signal bots, often cheaply. Pick Ethy when you want the market read and explained first, an idea tested from one sentence, and then run with stops on Hyperliquid and trade.xyz.

What do trading bots like 3Commas, Cryptohopper and Pionex do?

A classic trading bot runs a rule you set, on your exchange account, without a break. Our fuller definition of a trading bot covers the kinds, the keys and why even a good one fails. Three kinds cover most of what people run:

  • DCA bots (dollar-cost averaging) buy in pieces, on a schedule or each time the price drops by a set step, then sell when the price recovers to a target above the average cost. Our DCA backtest tests weekly buys against a lump sum over three years.
  • Grid bots place a ladder of buy orders below the price and sell orders above it, and re-place each order after it fills, collecting small gains while the price swings inside a range. Our guide to grid trading backtests one in a range and in a trend.
  • Signal bots trade when an outside signal arrives, often a TradingView alert sent by webhook, a message TradingView posts to the bot’s web address when your alert fires.

Here are five of the best known, from their own pages and app listings on November 15, 2026. Prices are in US dollars per month.

Classic trading bots compared, as of November 15, 2026
ToolWhat it isBots and toolsWhere it tradesPrice, November 2026
3CommasA bot platform that connects to your exchange accountsDCA, grid and signal bots (TradingView webhooks and Pine Script, TradingView’s scripting language), Smart Trade with trailing take profit and trailing stop loss, backtests on 1-minute candlesBinance, Coinbase, Kraken, OKX, Bybit, Bitget, Gate, KuCoin and HyperliquidStarter $20, Pro $50, Expert $140 ($15, $38 and $105 billed yearly); free trial
CryptohopperA bot platform with a no-code strategy designerTrading bot, DCA, trailing orders, paper trading, backtests, copy bot; market making, arbitrage and AI strategies on the top planBinance, Coinbase Advanced, Kraken, OKX, KuCoin, Crypto.com and four moreExplorer $29, Adventurer $69, Hero $129 ($24.16, $57.50 and $107.50 billed yearly); 3-day trial
PionexAn exchange with bots built in, so your money sits at PionexSpot and futures grid bots, an infinity grid, DCA and smart trade botsPionex itselfIts app lists a 0.05% trading fee
CoinruleAn if-this-then-that rule builder with 350+ templatesRules on price, indicators and time, backtests against simply holding, TradingView signals on the Trader and Pro plans25+ crypto exchanges, blockchains and stock brokers, Hyperliquid includedFree Starter; Investor $29.99, Trader $59.99, Pro $749
BitsgapA bot platform for spot and futures on connected exchangesGrid, DCA, BTD, LOOP, QFL and COMBO bots, smart orders and an AI Chat; backtests of 30, 180 or 365 days by plan17 exchanges, among them Binance, Coinbase Advanced, Kraken, OKX and HyperliquidFree plan with demo bots; Basic $29, Advanced $69, Pro $149 ($23, $55 and $119 billed yearly)

What they do well is real. Between them they connect to nearly every big exchange, they have years of work in their grid and DCA bots, with settings for most variations, and a simple bot can cost little or nothing. If you already know exactly what you want to run, a classic bot is often the quickest way to run it. Our list of the best AI trading bots compares 12 tools side by side, stock tools and AI agents included.

How do trading bots get access to your money?

Four of the five never hold your money. You create an API key on your exchange, a code that lets a program act on your account, and paste it into the bot. What the key can do depends on the permissions you choose when you create it: read balances, trade, and on some exchanges withdraw. Binance, for example, limits a standard key with no IP restriction (a list of the only internet addresses allowed to use it) to reading, and won’t let any key withdraw until that restriction is set.

That is why bot platforms tell you your money stays on the exchange: 3Commas says it “cannot withdraw your funds,” and Coinrule’s homepage reads “Your funds stay on your exchange.” A trade-only key can still lose money by trading, so treat it like a password, leave withdrawals off and delete keys you no longer use.

Pionex works the other way. It is the exchange, so you deposit with it and its bots trade the balance it holds for you.

Ethy is different again: there is no exchange account to connect. Your balance lives in a wallet that belongs to you, and you can export its key at any time. When you activate Ethy, its servers are allowed to sign for that wallet; that is how automations trade while you are offline. Sending money out of Ethy asks for your passkey once you have set one. Our guide to Hyperliquid trading bots explains the keys in detail.

Where do classic trading bots fall short?

For a trader who already knows the rule, very little. The gaps show up earlier, before the rule exists.

  • You still have to know what to set. A grid needs a price range and a number of levels, and a DCA bot needs its steps and a target. A grid’s classic failure is a wrong range: when the price breaks out of it, the bot is left holding a falling coin, or sold out of a rising one. The bot runs your settings; it doesn’t tell you whether they suit today’s market.
  • The rule engine doesn’t explain the market. It reads price, indicators, time and outside signals. It can’t tell you why a coin dropped this morning, or whether the reason changes your plan.
  • Backtests differ a lot. 3Commas tests on 1-minute candles, Bitsgap gives 30, 180 or 365 days depending on the plan, and Coinrule compares a template with simply holding. Before you trust a result, check how much history it covers and whether it counts trading fees and slippage, the gap between the price you expect and the price you get.
  • News sits outside the rule. None of the five offers news as a trigger on the pages we read, and Ethy’s automations can’t trigger on news either. The difference is that you can ask Ethy what happened before you set the rule or change it.

The line between bots and AI is blurring, and it is only fair to say so. 3Commas is opening early access to QuantPilot, which it describes as a platform where autonomous agents build, backtest and optimize strategies for you. Bitsgap’s AI Chat tells you whether a market is rising, falling or moving sideways, suggests a bot with a backtest and fills in its settings for you to launch. Cryptohopper’s top plan adds AI strategies and an AI strategy designer, and Coinrule offers an MCP connection, a standard way to plug AI assistants into other software, so an assistant can run its strategies. The question is no longer whether a tool has AI, but what that AI can read, what it can build and where it can trade. We ask the same of general assistants in Ethy vs ChatGPT and Ethy vs Claude.

What does Ethy do that a trading bot doesn’t?

Ethy is an AI trading agent you ask before you trade. A bot starts from settings; Ethy starts from a question.

It reads the market and explains it

Ask about a market and Ethy reads its chart on four timeframes together, the daily, 4-hour, 1-hour and 15-minute, and lists the levels that matter. Ask why it moved and it searches the web, cites its sources, and adds the latest quote and how related markets moved. It can also show positioning: funding (the payments between longs and shorts), open interest (the value of all open positions), and smart money against the crowd. That is the step a grid bot skips: is this market ranging, or is a trend starting?

It tests an idea from one sentence

Describe the rule the way you would to a friend: “buy SOL when the 4-hour RSI closes under 30, take profit at 6%, stop at 3%.” Ethy shows the rule as it understood it, backtests that exact rule on up to 365 days of history, marks every entry and exit on the chart, and reports the return, the worst drawdown (the biggest drop from a peak), the win rate and how it compares with simply holding. It can then optimize the settings, ranking them on one stretch of history and checking each candidate on a separate stretch it wasn’t tuned on, a guard against fitting the past.

This also answers a fair worry about AI agents: that they are harder to predict than a fixed rule. In this flow the AI reads and builds, and what trades is a rule you have seen and tested.

It runs the rule with limits around it

A tested rule becomes an automation. You press Activate once, live or in paper mode, which uses live prices and moves no money, and it trades by itself on Ethy’s servers. Each automation can carry a take profit, a stop loss and a trailing stop, plus a maximum daily loss, a maximum drawdown in dollars, trading-hours windows and a pause after 10 losing trades in a row, which is on by default and adjustable. On Hyperliquid, the stop loss and take profit are native orders, so they fire even when Ethy is closed, and every live trade sends you a notification.

It knows your trading plan

Your trading plan, your own rules for risk, markets, process and goals, is read first in every chat. When an idea goes against it, Ethy tells you before you act.

Where it trades

On Hyperliquid, Ethy trades perps (contracts with no expiry date that track a price): crypto on its main exchange, and stocks, indices, commodities and FX on trade.xyz, a market built on Hyperliquid. It also makes spot swaps on Base, X Layer and Robinhood Chain.

What it doesn’t do

  • It places no resting limit orders, so it doesn’t run a classic grid of orders waiting on the book. An entry at a level is an automation that trades at market when the level prints, and the Accumulation Grid template in Ethy’s Strategy Library also trades each level at market.
  • It doesn’t take TradingView alerts.
  • It doesn’t connect to centralized exchanges such as Binance or Kraken.
  • An automation can’t use one market to trade another (“buy ETH when BTC drops”), and Ethy runs one automation per Hyperliquid market per wallet, because Hyperliquid nets all trades in a market into one position.

Ethy or a trading bot: which is better for each job?

Here is the honest split, including the jobs where a classic bot is the better pick.

Ethy vs classic trading bots, job by job
JobClassic botEthyBetter pick
Grid trading a sideways marketA core product at Pionex, Bitsgap and 3Commas, refined over yearsAn Accumulation Grid template that trades each level at market, but no resting limit ordersClassic bot
A detailed DCA setupSteps, targets and many pairs at once, on most big exchangesScheduled buys (DCA) and orders split over time (TWAP) as automationsClassic bot; either one for simple scheduled buys
Turning TradingView alerts into ordersSignal bots built for it, such as 3Commas’ Signal Bot or Coinrule on its higher plansNot supportedClassic bot
Trading on Binance, Coinbase, Kraken or OKXConnects with an API keyDoesn’t connect to themClassic bot
Very fast rules and market makingGrid orders rest on the book and fill the moment price reaches them; Cryptohopper’s top plan adds market makingIndicator rules work on 15-minute to daily candlesA grid bot, or your own code
The lowest cost for one simple ruleA free Starter plan at Coinrule; Pionex lists only its trading feeA free plan, then monthly plansClassic bot, usually
Knowing whether the market suits the ruleYou judge it, or ask an AI chat added on top, as at BitsgapFour-timeframe chart read, key levels, why it moved with sources, funding and open interestEthy, for depth; Bitsgap’s AI Chat says if a coin is rising, falling or moving sideways
Testing an idea you can only put in wordsTemplates and builders, with AI assistants arrivingFrom one sentence to a tested rule, with the exact rule shown firstEthy, if the rule is your own; a bot’s AI if a standard bot fits
Limits beyond the stopVaries by product and planMax daily loss, max drawdown, trading hours, a pause after a losing streakEthy, or check each bot’s settings
StocksCoinrule connects to stock brokers, so its rules can trade real sharesStock perps on trade.xyz, which track the price but give you no shares, plus gold, oil and index perpsDepends: real shares at a broker, or perps on Hyperliquid
Checking a trade against your own planNot listed on the pages we readReads your trading plan first in every chatEthy

Rule bots and AI agents as categories, and the hybrid of the two, get their own article: trading bots vs AI agents. This page is about the choice in front of you. If the choice is whether to automate at all, see manual vs automated trading.

How do you choose between Ethy and a trading bot?

Four questions settle it for most traders.

  1. Do you already know the exact rule? If it is a grid or a DCA plan you have run before, use the bot built for it. If it is an idea you still need to check, start with a tool that reads the market and tests the idea first.
  2. Where do you trade? On Binance, Coinbase, Kraken or OKX, a classic bot connects with an API key. On Hyperliquid both work: 3Commas, Bitsgap and Coinrule connect to it, and Ethy trades its crypto perps and the stock, commodity, index and FX perps of trade.xyz.
  3. Do you need to know why before you trade? If you want the chart read, the reason behind a move and your own plan checked before each decision, that is what Ethy is for. If you only need execution, a bot is simpler.
  4. What does it cost you in full? Add the plan, any fee per trade and the exchange’s own fees, then compare the total with the size you trade. For one small, simple rule, a free tier often wins.

You don’t have to choose one forever. One sensible split is a DCA bot on a centralized exchange and Ethy for reading the market and running your Hyperliquid rules. Just don’t point two tools at the same market in the same Hyperliquid account: Hyperliquid nets every trade in a market into one position, so each tool would be moving the other’s position.

Summary

  • Classic bots such as 3Commas, Cryptohopper, Pionex, Coinrule and Bitsgap run a rule you already know, on the exchanges you already use, and they do grid and DCA well.
  • Most connect through an API key that can trade but, set up properly, can’t withdraw; Pionex is itself the exchange.
  • Their gap comes before the rule: a bot runs your grid range or DCA steps whether or not they suit today’s market, and news sits outside its triggers.
  • The gap is narrowing: QuantPilot at 3Commas, Bitsgap’s AI Chat, Cryptohopper’s AI and Coinrule’s MCP all put AI on top of bots.
  • Ethy starts from a question: it reads and explains the market, tests an idea from one sentence and runs it with stops and loss limits on Hyperliquid and trade.xyz.
  • Pick a classic bot for exchange coverage, mature grid and DCA, TradingView alerts, very fast rules and the lowest price; pick Ethy to understand the market and test your own idea first.

Questions people ask

Is Ethy a trading bot?

Not in the classic sense. A bot runs the settings you give it. Ethy is an AI trading agent: you ask it about a market, it reads the chart and the news behind a move, tests your idea on past data, and can then run it as an automation with stops and loss limits. The automation itself is a fixed rule, like a bot’s, which is what makes it testable.

Can Ethy run a grid bot?

Not a classic one. A grid bot keeps a ladder of limit orders resting on the order book and re-places each one after it fills. Ethy places no resting limit orders; an entry at a level is an automation that trades at market when the level prints. Its Strategy Library does have an Accumulation Grid template, which also trades each level at market. For classic grid trading, a dedicated grid bot such as those of Pionex, Bitsgap or 3Commas is the better tool.

Can I connect TradingView alerts to Ethy?

No. Ethy doesn’t take TradingView alerts or webhooks. If your strategy lives in TradingView, a signal bot such as 3Commas’ Signal Bot, or Coinrule on its higher plans, can turn those alerts into orders. With Ethy, you describe the rule in plain English instead, and Ethy backtests it and runs it.

Is 3Commas better than an AI agent?

For grid, DCA and TradingView signal bots on centralized exchanges such as Binance, Coinbase or Kraken, 3Commas is the more complete tool. For reading the market, finding out why it moved and testing an idea you describe in words before it runs, an AI agent such as Ethy does more. 3Commas is also opening early access to QuantPilot, its own AI platform.

Which costs less, Ethy or a trading bot?

For one simple rule, usually a bot. On November 15, 2026, Coinrule had a free Starter plan, Pionex listed only a 0.05% trading fee, 3Commas started at $20 a month and Cryptohopper at $29. Ethy is free to start with 500 credits, then Core at $15 a month, Pro at $59 or Max at $179. On Hyperliquid trades, Ethy adds a fee per fill of 0.030% to 0.100% depending on the plan, on top of Hyperliquid’s own fees and funding, and spot swaps carry 0.25% to 0.85%.

Can I use Ethy and a trading bot together?

Yes, on different accounts or markets. One sensible split is a bot for DCA or grids on a centralized exchange and Ethy for reading the market and running rules on Hyperliquid. Avoid two tools trading the same Hyperliquid market from the same account: Hyperliquid nets all trades in a market into one position, so each tool would move the other’s position.

Sources

  1. 3Commas: Crypto trading bots and automation platform (bots, exchanges, backtesting, QuantPilot)3commas.io
  2. 3Commas: Pricing3commas.io
  3. Cryptohopper: Pricingcryptohopper.com
  4. Cryptohopper: Supported crypto exchangescryptohopper.com
  5. Pionex: Crypto Trading Bots, App Store listing (updated October 22, 2026)apps.apple.com
  6. Coinrule: Crypto and stock trading bots (templates, backtests, supported platforms)coinrule.com
  7. Coinrule: Pricingcoinrule.com
  8. Bitsgap: Plans and pricingbitsgap.com
  9. Bitsgap: AI Chatbitsgap.com
  10. Binance: How to create API keys on Binancebinance.com

Trading involves risk, including the loss of your money. Ethy AI is a research and trading tool and does not give investment advice or recommendations. Backtests are simulations on historical data and do not predict future results.

Ethy blog

Read more

The $ETHY ecosystem

Stop watching charts.
Start living.

Deploy your AI trading agent in one click.