Both run crypto bots on your exchange account through API keys. They differ in how you build a strategy, what the AI does, how you test, and where each one is in its life. Here is the comparison, dated November 17, 2026.
November 17, 2026
11
min to read
The short answer
As of November 17, 2026, 3Commas is the pick for DCA, grid and signal bots driven by TradingView alerts, with a demo account and an AI assistant that builds the bot; it is mid-rebuild. Cryptohopper is the pick for a strategy marketplace, a paper bot and arbitrage. Both use exchange API keys: keep withdrawals off.
Both are crypto bot platforms that trade on an exchange account you already have, using an API key (a password-like key that lets one app place orders without being able to move your coins, if you set it up that way). Neither holds your funds. The difference is in how you get a strategy and in how settled the product is.
If you want each one on its own, read our 3Commas review and Cryptohopper review. Both draw on the companies’ own pages and help centers, read on November 17, 2026. We did not trade with either, and we do not quote star ratings or user reviews.
| 3Commas | Cryptohopper | |
|---|---|---|
| Bots | DCA bot (also indicator-based bots), signal bot for TradingView alerts and API requests, grid bot, and a Terminal for manual trades | A strategy-based cloud bot with a strategy designer, DCA features, event-based triggers, portfolio and manual bots, short selling, a Copy Bot, and exchange arbitrage, triangular arbitrage and market-making bots |
| Exchanges | Nine: Binance, Hyperliquid, Bybit, OKX, Bitget, Gate, Kraken, KuCoin, Coinbase | Ten: Binance, KuCoin, HTX, Bitvavo, OKX, Kraken, Binance.us, Crypto.com, BingX, Coinbase |
| Backtesting | The AI assistant runs a backtest in the chat before launch | A backtester in beta: a small daily allowance by plan, one run at a time, no triggers or TradingView alerts |
| Paper trading | A demo account: $10,000 of virtual funds, real-time prices, perpetual markets, up to two accounts | A paper bot with real exchange data and simulated funds, one per subscription |
| AI features | An AI assistant that configures, backtests and launches a bot, on paid plans; an MCP server that lets your own AI app work with your account | Algorithm Intelligence ranks several strategies and switches to the one it rates best; AI strategies and an AI designer; a market-data MCP server for your own AI app |
| Marketplace or copy | None described in the V2 guides we read; DCA bot presets replace the old Strategy Gallery | A marketplace of strategies, templates and signals; a Copy Bot that copies a trader you pick |
| Mobile app | The V2 guide says the V1 apps are being removed and V2 apps are expected later | iOS and Android app, with a paper-bot guide in its docs |
| Suits | Traders who want DCA, grid or alert-driven bots and a demo account, and can ride out a rebuild | Traders who want a cloud bot with a strategy marketplace and a paper bot |
Sources: 3Commas migration guide, AI page, demo guide, MCP guide, Cryptohopper home page, pricing, backtester docs, Copy Bot docs and MCP docs.
3Commas gives you a short menu of bot types and an assistant that fills in the settings. On the DCA bot, V2 also holds the indicator-based bots, such as RSI; the signal bot takes TradingView and API alerts; and webhook and Pine Script execution (TradingView’s scripting language) are on every plan. The Terminal can place one trade across up to 50 API keys. If your edge is an alert from TradingView, this is the more direct route. The shapes of those bots are explained in the DCA guide and the grid bot guide.
Cryptohopper gives you a designer and a marketplace. You can build a strategy, or buy a strategy or bot template, and run it in the cloud. It also has a Copy Bot that follows a trader you pick, and arbitrage and market-making bots, and your plan caps how many coins and open positions the bot can handle. Each subscription runs one live bot and one paper bot.
A marketplace saves time and also invites a caution: a strategy someone sells you is still someone else’s past results. Test it first, on the paper bot.
They use the word “AI” for different jobs, which is why the label alone tells you little.
If you want to start from a sentence, 3Commas’ assistant is closer to that. If you already have several strategies and want one chosen for you, Cryptohopper’s is. Neither built-in AI is a chat where you ask about a chart before you trade: both configure a bot, a fixed set of rules. Why that matters is in Ethy vs trading bots.
Both also let you bring your own AI app, such as Claude or Cursor, through MCP (Model Context Protocol, a standard way for AI apps to use outside tools), and the two connections do different things. 3Commas’ MCP guide connects the app to your account, to check strategies and history or open and close strategies when you ask. Cryptohopper’s Market Data MCP gives the app order books, tickers and candles.
Both let you practice, in different ways. 3Commas’ demo account starts with $10,000 of virtual funds, resets on request, uses real-time prices and trades the perpetual markets only. Cryptohopper’s paper bot uses real exchange data with simulated funds, and each subscription includes one, on one exchange. On past data, 3Commas’ assistant backtests inside the chat, and Cryptohopper’s backtester is a beta with a small daily allowance.
A backtest shows how a rule would have behaved, a paper run shows how it behaves now without risk, and neither shows what a real fill costs you. How to read a backtest is in our backtesting guide.
On how they work, they are alike. Neither holds your funds. 3Commas’ security page says it “has zero access to withdraw or transfer fiat or cryptocurrencies”; Cryptohopper’s support center says “Cryptohopper does not need withdrawal permissions.” Create keys with trade rights only, an IP restriction and no withdrawals on either.
On history, both have incidents, in the companies’ own words:
Only 3Commas says users’ API keys were exposed; Cryptohopper says its 2022 breach did not include them. Neither history makes a product unsafe today, and neither proves it safe. What reduces your risk is the key you create, not the logo. Our reviews go deeper: 3Commas and Cryptohopper.
Pionex is a different shape. 3Commas and Cryptohopper are bot software that connects to an exchange you already use. Pionex is an exchange with its bots built in: its platform overview says it got its start as “the world’s first exchange with a built-in crypto trading bot,” and lists spot bots such as grid, DCA and rebalancing bots, plus futures grid bots. Its grid bot FAQ describes withdrawn profits, and a stopped bot’s coins, going back to your Pionex “Primary Account,” with no API key involved.
That changes the trade-off. With 3Commas or Cryptohopper, your coins sit at an exchange of your choice and a key is the risk. With Pionex, you deposit on the platform that runs the bot, so the exchange holds your coins and the question becomes whether you trust that exchange. If you want the least setup, Pionex avoids keys altogether. If you want to keep your coins where they are, the other two do. The full picture is in our Pionex review.
Ethy does a different job from either. 3Commas and Cryptohopper run a bot on your exchange account once you have set it up. Ethy is an AI trading agent you ask before you trade: you ask about a chart and get a read on four timeframes at once (1D, 4H, 1H and 15m), describe an idea in plain words, and Ethy backtests that exact rule on up to 365 days across up to 10 markets, with every entry and exit marked. Then it runs it on paper or live, on its servers, around the clock.
It trades Hyperliquid perps, which cover crypto and trade.xyz’s stocks, commodities, indices and FX, and token swaps on Base, X Layer and Robinhood Chain. It has no strategy marketplace and does not copy other traders’ wallets today. Many traders would use both kinds: a bot platform for exchange-based DCA or grids, and an agent to test an idea first. More in Ethy vs trading bots.
Nine exchanges at 3Commas, ten at Cryptohopper. The lists overlap on Binance, OKX, Kraken, KuCoin and Coinbase. Hyperliquid, Bybit, Bitget and Gate are on 3Commas’ main list; HTX, Bitvavo, Binance.us, Crypto.com and BingX are on Cryptohopper’s.
An alert or a sentence you write (3Commas), or a designer and a marketplace (Cryptohopper).
Futures at 3Commas, and the AI tools, arbitrage and market making at Cryptohopper, are not on every plan. See the pricing FAQ.
Use the demo account or the paper bot for a few weeks.
Trade only, no withdrawals, an IP restriction, and a size you could lose in full.
Neither wins on every point. 3Commas suits DCA, grid and alert-driven bots with a demo account and an AI assistant, and is mid-rebuild after V1 closed on September 11, 2026. Cryptohopper suits a cloud bot with a strategy marketplace and a paper bot. Pick by your exchange, the plan you need and how you want to test.
Both say they cannot withdraw your funds and need no withdrawal permission. Both have published incidents: 3Commas’ December 2022 key disclosure, at least 100,000 keys by its own FAQ, and Cryptohopper’s 2022 and 2024 posts. Safety comes mostly from your key: trade only, no withdrawals, an IP restriction.
It is a different model: an exchange with bots built in, so you deposit on Pionex instead of connecting a key. That removes the key risk and puts your coins on its platform. Which is better depends on whether you want to keep your coins at your own exchange.
Yes, they are separate services using separate API keys, so you can run one on each, even on the same exchange. Give each its own trade-only key, and watch for two bots trading the same pair, which can cancel each other out. Test each on its demo or paper bot first.
Yes, both have an MCP server, and they do different things. 3Commas’ connects your AI app to your 3Commas account, to check strategies and history or open and close strategies when you ask; it suggests a read-only key for questions. Cryptohopper’s Market Data MCP gives your app order books, tickers and candles. Neither is a built-in chat about charts.
On November 17, 2026: 3Commas Starter $20 a month, Pro $50, Expert $140, or $15, $38 and $105 a month billed yearly, with a free trial; Starter is spot only and futures start on Pro. Cryptohopper Explorer $29, Adventurer $69, Hero $129, or $24.16, $57.50 and $107.50 billed yearly, before VAT, with a three-day trial of Explorer; AI tools, arbitrage and market making are on Hero. Ethy has a free plan with 500 credits, then $15, $59 or $179 a month.
Trading involves risk, including the loss of your money. Ethy AI is a research and trading tool and does not give investment advice or recommendations. Backtests are simulations on historical data and do not predict future results.
Deploy your AI trading agent in one click.
