Your AI trading operator. Working 24/7 so you don't have to.
Tools and comparisons
Coinrule review: if-then trading bots, API keys and what it costs
Coinrule lets you build trading bots as simple if-then rules and runs them on your own exchange account. Here is what it does well, how its API keys work, what it says about safety, and who should look elsewhere.
Coinrule is a no-code tool where you build bots as if-then rules, such as buy BTC if it drops 5% in 24 hours, and run them on your own exchange or broker through an API key. It says that key has no withdrawal permission. It offers backtests and a demo exchange, and says it is not a regulated financial institution.
What is Coinrule?
Coinrule, from Coinrule Ltd, is a platform for building automated trading strategies, which it calls rules or bots, without writing code. Its site describes “a crypto trading bot platform” for crypto, stocks and ETFs, and gives an example of what a rule looks like: “Buy BTC if it drops 5% in 24 hours” or “Take profit when ETH rises 10% trailing,” run around the clock (Coinrule, read November 17, 2026). Y Combinator’s company page lists Coinrule in its Summer 2021 batch, founded in 2018 and based in London (Y Combinator).
The key design point is that Coinrule does not hold your money. You connect an account you already have, and Coinrule places trades there. As of November 17, 2026, the site lists exchanges such as Binance, Coinbase, Kraken, OKX, KuCoin, Bybit, Bitget and Hyperliquid, onchain trading on Base, Arbitrum and BSC, and stock and ETF brokers such as Trading 212, Webull, Alpaca, Robinhood and Tastytrade. The site gives the count as “25+” in one place and “20+” in another, so we name examples rather than a number. If you are new to the idea, what a trading bot is covers the basics first.
Coinrule also offers an AI layer called Coinrule AI Cloud. Its help center describes it as a platform “that helps users create, validate, test, deploy, and monitor trading strategies,” combining AI, trading agents, rule-based execution, backtesting, paper trading and connections to AI assistants (Coinrule AI Cloud, updated October 19, 2026). The page is careful to say that AI-generated strategies, backtests and optimization suggestions do not ensure profitable results, which is the right tone.
What does Coinrule do well?
Rules you can read. A visual builder lets you pick conditions and actions, and the logic stays visible. Coinrule says you can also start from a library of 350-plus templates, and change the coin, trigger, size or exit. That is a good fit for people who want to know exactly why a bot trades.
It uses your account, not a pooled one. Your funds stay at your exchange or broker. A bot is only the instructions, and deleting its key stops it.
Many venues in one tool. Crypto exchanges, a few onchain routes and several stock brokers sit behind the same builder, so you can build rules for crypto and for stocks in one place.
A way to try before you risk money. Coinrule has a Demo Exchange that runs your rules on virtual funds. Its help page, last updated November 5, 2024, says the demo wallet starts with 10 BTC and 10,000 USDT and runs as paper trading on Binance with real-time prices (How the Demo Exchange works). The AI Cloud page adds that backtests run on historical data and that its paper-trading environment gives a virtual $10,000 USDT balance per strategy.
TradingView signals. Coinrule says a TradingView alert, including one from a Pine Script strategy, can trigger an order on your connected exchange. If you already build signals on TradingView, that is a real bridge.
It works with the AI assistants you already use. Coinrule’s docs say you can connect Claude, ChatGPT, Grok or another MCP client to your account (MCP is the standard that lets an AI app use outside tools), so the assistant can read balances, run backtests, build strategies and trade. You choose read-only or read-and-write access, and you can revoke it (Coinrule MCP docs).
A mobile app and a free plan. The site lists iOS and Android apps and a free plan with limits. The free plan is in the pricing answer below.
For the grid and DCA bots that many people want, Coinrule’s FAQ says you can build them as rules. For how each works, see grid trading bots and DCA in crypto.
How does Coinrule connect to your exchange, and what can its key do?
An API key is a long code you create inside your exchange account. You paste it into Coinrule, and Coinrule uses it to place orders for you. When you create the key, the exchange asks what it may do. Typical choices are read (see balances), trade (place and cancel orders) and withdraw (move money out).
Coinrule’s guidance is to leave withdraw off. Its Binance setup guide says Coinrule “doesn’t need any withdrawal permissions, so for your own security, you don’t have to select this option,” and tells you to restrict the key to trusted IP addresses by copying Coinrule’s list into Binance (Coinrule Binance API setup). The home page says Coinrule is non-custodial, uses API connections with no withdrawal permissions, and encrypts your keys with AES-256. Those are Coinrule’s own statements.
What this means in practice:
A trade-only key cannot take your coins out. If someone stole it, they could place trades on your account, which can still do harm, but could not send funds to their address. An IP whitelist narrows even that.
You hold the off switch. Delete the key in your exchange and Coinrule can no longer act.
Use a key for Coinrule alone. Do not reuse a key between tools. If one tool has a problem, you revoke one key.
Is Coinrule safe, and is it legit?
Here is what the sources show, with their dates. We do not rate Coinrule.
Custody. By its own account, Coinrule does not hold your funds and cannot withdraw them. The weak point to watch is the key itself: what permissions you gave it, and where you stored it.
What Coinrule says about itself. Its footer, read November 17, 2026, says “Coinrule is not a regulated financial institution and does not provide investment advice,” that trading involves significant risk, that past performance is not indicative of future results, and that any performance figures it shows are for illustration only. Take that at face value: Coinrule labels the sample backtest on its home page a simulation based on representative patterns, not actual trading results, so we do not quote it.
Who is behind it. The site names Coinrule Ltd and lists a founding team: Gabriele Musella (CEO), Zdeněk Höfler (CTO) and Oleg Giberstein, a non-executive director. Y Combinator lists Coinrule in its Summer 2021 batch and names Musella and Höfler as founders.
History. Coinrule’s site and help center describe no security incident. For what a key leak at a bot service looks like, see the one at 3Commas in December 2022, covered in our 3Commas review; it is the reason a key with no withdrawal right matters.
Reviews. Coinrule’s home page shows its own rating badges and user quotes. Those are marketing, so we do not repeat them. If you read reviews, read them on the review site itself and check their dates.
The US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) issued a customer advisory on January 25, 2024, titled “AI Won’t Turn Trading Bots into Money Machines” (CFTC press release); the page now writes SI, for super intelligence, where most people would say AI. It warns that fraudsters use the hype to sell automated trading algorithms, signal services and crypto schemes that promise unreasonably high or certain returns, and tells you to research the background of the company or trader before you trust it with money (CFTC customer advisory). The CFTC does not name Coinrule. It is a checklist for the whole category: a bot runs your rules, it does not predict the market. Our guide to whether AI trading is legit walks through how to check any product.
Where does Coinrule stop?
It runs rules you write. The AI Cloud page says it plainly: “AI helps develop the strategy, while the configured rules govern execution.” If you do not yet know what rule to write, Coinrule helps you build one, but it is not built around asking what a chart is saying first.
Plan limits. Its pricing page limits the number of live rules, conditions per rule, connected exchanges and monthly volume by plan, and the free plan is small. Check the limits before you build on one.
Practice fills are kinder than live ones. The Demo Exchange fills at the best price on Binance’s order book, and Coinrule says results can differ from live trading on low-volume coins with less liquidity. The AI Cloud page says its paper trading does not reproduce actual exchange fees or slippage. Either way, a demo result can look better than a live one.
Few details on its backtests. The AI Cloud page says backtests run on historical data, but it does not say how many months of data they use or which results you get. Check that in the product before you rely on a result.
Only as good as the rule. A rule such as “buy the dip” can keep buying a market that keeps falling. Nothing in Coinrule changes that.
Who is Coinrule for, and who should look elsewhere?
Coinrule suits you if
you already trade on an exchange or broker and want rules to run there while you sleep;
you know, or can state, the rule you want, and like seeing its logic;
you use TradingView alerts and want them to trigger orders;
you want a demo mode first and an AI assistant that can work with your account.
Look elsewhere if
you want ready-made exchange bots with the money inside the exchange: Pionex is built that way;
you want bot types with their own settings, such as DCA, grid and signal bots, rather than rules you assemble: see our 3Commas review and Cryptohopper review;
you want to ask first and understand a chart before you write any rule, then test the idea on past data with its full results in front of you.
What are the alternatives to Coinrule?
Pick by what you want from the tool.
An exchange with bots built in:Pionex. The setup is shorter, and your money sits on that exchange.
Ask first, test, then trade: Ethy, an AI trading agent you ask before you trade. You describe an idea in plain words, Ethy reads the chart on four timeframes, backtests the rule on past data (up to 365 days, up to 10 markets in a run, with every entry and exit marked) and can run it on paper or live, with stop loss, take profit and a daily loss limit. It trades Hyperliquid perps, including stocks, indices, commodities and currencies on trade.xyz, from one USDC balance, plus token swaps on Base. Where Coinrule is ahead: it reaches far more exchanges and brokers, takes TradingView alerts, and works with Claude and ChatGPT, none of which Ethy does today. On custody: your Ethy balance lives in a wallet that belongs to you, and you can export its key at any time; Ethy is set up to sign for that wallet from its servers so automations can trade without a pop-up.
Coinrule, Pionex and Ethy compared, November 17, 2026
How it works
Where your money is
Test before real money
Best for
Coinrule
If-then rules you build, run on your exchange or broker
Your own account, reached by an API key
Backtests and a demo exchange on virtual funds
Readable rules across many venues
Pionex
Set bots inside its own exchange
In your Pionex account, held by Pionex
Futures Demo Trading; backtest figures on some bot pages
The shortest start with grid and DCA bots
Ethy
You ask in chat; it reads, backtests and can run the rule
A wallet that belongs to you; Ethy signs for it from its servers
Backtests up to 365 days and paper mode
Checking an idea before you trade it, on Hyperliquid
How do you decide whether Coinrule is right for you?
Write the rule in one sentence first
If you cannot say it plainly, such as “buy 50 dollars of ETH each time it falls 5%, never more than 500 in a week,” a builder will not fix that.
Create a key that can only trade
Leave withdraw off, restrict the key to Coinrule’s IP addresses where your exchange allows it, and use the key for nothing else.
Run it on the demo exchange
Watch how the rule behaves with no money at stake, remembering that demo orders fill at the best quoted price, so a thin market can fill worse when it is live.
Go live small
Start with an amount you can lose. Check the rule often in the first weeks.
Distrust any promise of steady profit
The CFTC calls claims of high returns a red flag of fraud. A rule follows its conditions; it does not know the next move.
Summary
Coinrule builds trading bots as if-then rules and runs them on your own exchange or broker account through an API key, with 350-plus templates.
Coinrule says its connections need no withdrawal permission and that your funds stay at your exchange; its Binance guide tells you to leave withdraw off and whitelist its IP addresses.
It offers backtesting, a Demo Exchange on virtual funds that fills at the best quoted price, TradingView signals and an MCP connection to Claude and ChatGPT.
Its footer says it is not a regulated financial institution and does not give investment advice; Y Combinator lists it in its Summer 2021 batch, founded in 2018.
Alternatives: Pionex for bots inside an exchange, 3Commas or Cryptohopper for other bot platforms on your exchange, free options, or Ethy to ask, backtest and then trade.
Questions people ask
Is Coinrule legit?
Coinrule is a working product from Coinrule Ltd, a London company that Y Combinator lists in its Summer 2021 batch, with public pricing, help pages and docs. It says it is not a regulated financial institution and does not give investment advice. Its bots follow your rules and can lose money, so start small.
Is Coinrule safe?
Coinrule says it never holds your funds and that its API connections have no withdrawal permission. Its setup guide tells you to leave withdraw off and restrict the key to trusted IP addresses. Those are the company’s own statements. The risks that remain are a leaked key and a bad rule.
Does Coinrule have a free plan?
Yes. Coinrule has a free Starter plan with limits on running strategies, templates, connected exchanges and monthly volume, plus a Demo Exchange on virtual funds. The exact limits are in the pricing answer below.
How much does Coinrule cost?
From Coinrule’s pricing page, read November 17, 2026: Starter is free (2 running strategies, 1 connected exchange, $3k monthly volume). Billed yearly, Investor is $29.99 a month ($359 a year), Trader $59.99 ($719) and Pro $749 ($8,988). Billed monthly, they are $39.99, $79.99 and $995. The price cards on Coinrule’s home page show Pro at $449.99 a month, so check the pricing page before you buy.
Can Claude or ChatGPT use Coinrule?
Yes. Coinrule’s docs say Claude, ChatGPT, Grok and other MCP clients can connect to your account to read balances, run backtests, build strategies and trade. You pick read-only or read-and-write access and can revoke it. Ethy has no connector like that today: you use it in its own app.
How is Ethy different from Coinrule?
Coinrule runs if-then rules on your exchange or broker and reaches many venues. Ethy is an AI trading agent you ask before you trade: it reads the chart, backtests an idea on past data and can run it on paper or live on Hyperliquid, including trade.xyz stocks and commodities. Coinrule takes TradingView alerts and works with Claude and ChatGPT; Ethy does neither today.
Trading involves risk, including the loss of your money. Ethy AI is a research and trading tool and does not give investment advice or recommendations. Backtests are simulations on historical data and do not predict future results.